That doesn't follow at all. The program could have been deficient. The placement program could have been fraudulent. And yet the student could make up the deficiency with other training and compete, as hopeless as that might be, against others in the same boat.
It isn't unusual for schools to defraud students by gaming placement by, for example, providing a pitiful amount of seed money for business majors to set off in a leaky lifeboat, or by forcing law students in lower-tier law schools to drop out before graduating.
You also have to consider that debt repayment in constant payments pays down very little principle at first. A student may have paid a lot of interest, but their debt remains high.
She should have known that for-profit colleges are bullshit before signing her life away to one. Now she wants to have her cake and eat it too by refusing to pay her loans, while still deriving benefit from the supposedly worthless degree she got.
We need a better solution to higher education. But this isn't it. I'm glad she's raising awareness of this issue, but she and everyone else involved needs to pay back at least some of her loan. You can't just expect the government to absolve you of your bad decisions.
Great argument.
If that's the case, I can send you a degree from WhafroU via PDF for a tidy sum within an hour. Get in touch, folks!
I don't think people really understand what they're saying when they say that people shouldn't have to pay back these loans. The loans are going to get repayed, it's just a question of who. You can't take it out of the defunct college, those people, and that money, are gone. Basically you're saying that taxpayers should foot the bill. You want to pay the government back out of your own pocket? Because that's what this means.
And anyways, we shouldn't even be debating this. University should be free, period. And yes, I know "free" = "we" = "our pockets". That's perfectly fine. Or we should start funding plane tickets and visas to send low income people to these countries[1] for study; requiring them to maintain a quality GPA or something. The world would be a better place for all of us if the "haves" weren't so adverse to paying for the "have-nots".
1. http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/worldviews/wp/2014/10/29...
Altruism's great and all, but you need to think very hard about what it means to provide a benefit to everyone. It's not just the people who were legitimately scammed.
I agree she shouldn't have to pay all of the debt, but surely the degree isn't totally worthless.