Re:Marijuana may be even safer than previously thought, rese...
by taion on Monday February 23, 2015 @12:33PM
(#9095587)
There's an extremely extremely rough utilitarian analysis that says that the largest positive effect in QALYs added comes from fewer road traffic deaths due to people substituting away from driving while drunk to driving while stoned. See section IV of http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/01/05/marijuana-much-more-tha...
Re:Marijuana may be even safer than previously thought, rese...
by nitrogen on Monday February 23, 2015 @12:32PM
(#9095580)
I'd rather just replace the ignition system with a short driving game that you have to complete to start the car
I've heard there are cars with a breath analyzer connected to the ignition. A driving game would hopefully pick up more than alcohol, so I like that idea. Unfortunately, I suspect many drunk drivers will just do what they do with the current systems and have their sober girlfriend pass the test for them.
Re:Marijuana may be even safer than previously thought, rese...
by fnordfnordfnord on Monday February 23, 2015 @01:50PM
(#9096102)
There is no breath analyzer for pot, or for other drugs, and the only tests available give results that aren't directly related to impairment. ie: A habitual user who isn't impaired can test the same as a casual user who is.
Re:Marijuana may be even safer than previously thought, rese...
by lotsofmangos on Monday February 23, 2015 @12:50PM
(#9095691)
have their sober girlfriend pass the test for them.
Good point. It needs some form of seat sensor that turns the engine back off if the person in the driving seat changes.
Re:Marijuana may be even safer than previously thought, rese...
by nitrogen on Monday February 23, 2015 @09:47PM
(#9098435)
Even that's not enough, though; the girlfriend might just lean over from the passenger seat. This is based on third hand information I've heard, not on anybody I actually know.
Re:Marijuana may be even safer than previously thought, rese...
by josefresco on Monday February 23, 2015 @12:27PM
(#9095535)
Or replace the need for an active driver at all. Seems like we're already flirting with this scenario with the lane-assist, adaptive cruise control etc.
The question then becomes, if an active/traditional "driver" is not needed, can the occupants be intoxicated?
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Science-Marijuana-Leslie-L-Iversen/d...
Now personally I do not think it is at all a good idea to drive when stoned, but I do not consider it anywhere near as dangerous as driving when drunk.
Same goes for a lot of other drugs. I'd rather get in a car with someone driving on LSD than on alcohol. They might think the other cars are penguins, but their reaction time if the penguins get too close is still going to be reasonable.
People who drive under the influence of any mind altering substance (be it alcohol or weed) should have their driving privileges taken away
Caffine and most painkillers fall into this definition. I'd rather just replace the ignition system with a short driving game that you have to complete to start the car.