Ah, proprietary addons. I've always wondered would selling AGPL exceptions work? I thought it did for gitorious.
If you don't distribute the product you don't have to share your contributions if I understand the AGPL correctly. Most users of GitLab use it internally and never distribute the code outside of the organization. If they do so they will share the source code anyway since almost all of it is written in interpreted languages like Ruby.
We think that repository hosting will be like email hosting. Most people will have an account for free with only forum support (similar to gmail and outlook.com). For the next few years we expect the on-premises subscriptions to bring in more than enough money to pay for hosting. Because code hosting is a central hub for many services we think that long term revenue model will be a marketplace for additional services.
Please let me know if you have any questions.