Re:How A Nerd Decides To Get The H1N1 Vaccine
by gloob on Wednesday October 28, 2009 @07:53PM
(#909160)
Sometimes I get the feeling that if I got a needle and was hit by a car two weeks later, I could convince people it was a side-effect.
I had my ribcage sawn open by the medical system so they could cut out a piece of my heart and replace it with a chunk of a pig's. I'm still around and doing just dandy. My suspicion is that the people who can do that sort of thing probably have a better notion of what this vaccine will do than I do.
Not that any of this invalidates any of your arguments, of course; I'm just talking.
Edit: Perhaps another way of looking at it would be: I don't really want a doctor who has never written a line of code in his life to tell me how to write a program. I suspect that modern medicine is not quackery and does involve actual expertise, and (equally significantly) that the medical system has a greater amount of medical expertise than I do.
Consider this poor woman who got dystonia after receiving a flu vaccine: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cEN5KGwNGeo
She was a cheerleader and how she can't walk.
The nerd logic also neglects the probability that the flu vaccine will actually help. In the lab, 50-80% of the vaccinated resisted the exact same strain, however in the wild, only 10% did not get the flu and the number of hospitalizations was not affected at all.
To do a proper analysis, one must use proper probabilities and statistics and consider the probabilities of outcome with the benefit/harm that could be caused by that outcome.