Re:Statements about the Mobile Web
by throwaway41597 on Saturday February 21, 2015 @04:37AM
(#9085160)
Re (1), doing full-page rendering on the server is not up to the current state of mobile apps. You can already partially update a page. Zero latency is on par as well on the mobile web, as a web app can load its code on the first render, store some data for offline (though this is a lot more work than it is on native because of the bad state of web databases implementations) and request data to the server when it doesn't fit on a phone's memory (surely, the native Quora app doesn't store its terabytes of data on every phone)
(2) is bit hand-wavy in my opinion
(3) is spot on, bookmarking to homescreen is something people don't know about; typing a password is okay if it's only once I think
(4) is about prioritizing resources to the most popular platform: a website on desktop, a native app on mobile
1) Is the result of shops putting all their dev effort into apps. Performant and high-quality mobile sites is easily achievable if you put in the effort. Native obviously has some advantages that can't be replicated in browser, but in-browser is repeatable across platforms and prevents lock-in (for both site creators and consumers)
2) To each his own. I've never really figured out what a native look and feel was since every app looks different. And it's not like non-native slowed down adoption of the WWW for desktops.
3) Bookmarks. Android at least lets you put a URL bookmark on your desktop too.
4) Same as 1.
2. With my iPhone at least, I enjoy the predictable user interface that comes with doing stuff inside IOS.
3. I'll be honest. I don't like typing in URLS on my phone, and typing in passwords. It is a real pain when alternatively I could just click an app.
4. I really hate the mobile sites for some companies. The mobile site for my school is awful and always redirects you to some ugly main menus from the page you actually wanted. I would much rather just have the regular website.