News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Lucas, Spielberg and Kasdan Created 'Raiders of the L... by threeseed on Friday February 20, 2015 @06:38PM (#9083828)
I think it's more a case of how well the special effects was done regardless of whether it's CGI or not.

Jurassic Park for me still looks as real now as it did back then.

Re:How Lucas, Spielberg and Kasdan Created 'Raiders of the L... by Crito on Friday February 20, 2015 @07:19PM (#9084003)
I think there is also an element of how we watch movie scenes today, compared with how it was done in the past.

For instance, if you want to see the ending of Terminator with the stop-motion animation, today you'd just go to youtube and watch it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2KeniFoiT-0

It looks pretty decent, but that's not really terrifying anymore like people remember it.

In the past though, if you wanted to see that scene, you probably sat through the entire movie. When you do that, I think the effects in that scene work much better. That is because the rest of the movie was conditioning you, getting you excited. Setting the stage for how things in that universe work and look. Seen within the full context of their movies, old special effects hold up much better IMHO.

Another movie where I think this is in strong effect is the original Robocop. ED-209 in the boardroom is much more effective after sitting through the opening of the film.

Re:How Lucas, Spielberg and Kasdan Created 'Raiders of the L... by mikepurvis on Friday February 20, 2015 @08:44PM (#9084303)
See, it's funny, because I actually got to see Jurassic Park again recently on a big screen.

On the one hand, I certainly found it immersive as a piece of storytelling, but I could also clearly see the transition between CGI dinosaurs and puppet ones. The flipping between methods didn't trick me as well as it has sometimes in the past.

Re:How Lucas, Spielberg and Kasdan Created 'Raiders of the L... by angersock on Saturday February 21, 2015 @02:26AM (#9084993)
Probably the best practical SFX I've ever seen would have to be John Carpenter's The Thing. The way the monsters worked--goddamn, shivers up my spine. Also, one of the tightest and suspenseful movies there is, even after the first viewing.
Re:How Lucas, Spielberg and Kasdan Created 'Raiders of the L... by aamar on Friday February 20, 2015 @09:19PM (#9084401)
I'd add the vivid and memorable CGI characters of Gollum and the T-1000. Also, many Pixar and post-merger Disney creations, though maybe a different standard applies there.