It's amusing that you feel you've "wrung out" of me something one of the few things I've recently blogged at length about.
You've blogged, "Don't use TrueCrypt"?
And no, I blogged "don't use sector-level crypto". In a post literally titled "You Don't Want XTS". Under the subhed "Disks Are The Last Thing You Want To Encrypt". As in, "the last thing in the world".
> This piece is written for software designers, not end-users. If you’re an end-user looking for crypto advice: use Truecrypt, use Filevault, use dm-crypt
I really just don't get why you'd, in one breath, decry XTS, and then in that same breath, recommend people use TrueCrypt, which is, as you call it, "the best-known implementation of XTS".
Maybe just lead me to the water on this one. It's really the only thing left unresolved in our conversation.
What's weird to me is why we have a gigantic thread dedicated to the precise nuances of what I think about Truecrypt. Isn't this incredibly boring?
If you'd care to elaborate beyond, "nuh uh", I'm sure we'd all be glad to hear it.
Edit:
Having re-read the thread, you haven't explained why you're involved in the TrueCrypt audit, or why you recommend folks use TrueCrypt if you think XTS is bad.
TrueCrypt lets you create fixed sized encrypted volumes, and allows you to decrypt those volumes on any of the three major OS platforms.
There's nothing special about TrueCrypt in how it performs the encryption/decryption (or so we're told), but no tool besides TrueCrypt allows such a flexible approach.
And it's you who refuses to accept that [secure,easy] can exist, because it'd make you irrelevant. It's a completely silly stance to take, but it's yours.
But hey, at least I've wrung your opinion on TrueCrypt out of you:
> By encouraging people to rely on tools like Truecrypt, you are, in a very small but real way, endangering them.
For posterity, in case you edit it away.
Which leads me to the question: Why are you even involved in the TrueCrypt audit, if you think it's a bad idea to use such tools?
P.S. Ulbricht was caught because the FBI owned TOR, and that's about it. Maybe your indignation towards TrueCrypt should consider Snowden's use of TrueCrypt to evade the combined allied world's intelligence community.