> Is it possible to lower your requirements or change how VLC works/can do when it is sandboxed?
Maybe for some, but not for others. You really need to be able to open a file without file opener. Opening optical disks is really important too. I don't get why read-only access to a device poses so much threats but I'm probably missing something.
FYI, so far, libpulse links to x11.
Re:First fully sandboxed Linux desktop app
by sp332 on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @11:47AM
(#9063238)
Low-level access to a device would let you read data from files that you don't have permission to read at the filesystem level.
Re:First fully sandboxed Linux desktop app
by asveikau on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @12:04PM
(#9063390)
You can set different permissions for different devices, you are aware of that right? I can say my DVD drive is readable by gid x, but not the partitions on my hard disk... This is already what Linux distros are doing.
Re:First fully sandboxed Linux desktop app
by edohyiez on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @12:16PM
(#9063482)
Then the media player can read every DVD you put into your drive as long as its running. So you always have to close the media player before inserting a DVD containing private files.
That probably isn't that important for DVDs, but for other devices (e.g. microphone, webcam) it certainly is.
Re:First fully sandboxed Linux desktop app
by tormeh on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @04:43PM
(#9065262)
>You really need to be able to open a file without file opener
What if you had read/write access to /home/user/music and /home/user/video ? Once we start adding blanket access like this we would probably need to add a /home/user/secret folder that no application can access unless invited to a specific file by a file opener.
It seems pretty impossible to create something which: 1) does sandboxing 2) has no limitations on what an application can do
Edit: What I meant is: Is it possible to lower your requirements or change how VLC works/can do when it is sandboxed?