Re:Ask HN: Why don't startups outsource/offshore development...
by joesmo on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @09:56AM
(#9062487)
Why wouldn't you control the IP with outsourced development? Obviously, any competent company would make the outsourced developers / development house hand over all rights to anything they produce under contract so this would be a non-issue.
Re:Ask HN: Why don't startups outsource/offshore development...
by eropple on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @10:16AM
(#9062628)
YM, of course, MV, but I've worked with outsourced teams (plural) before and the decisions I've observed have suggested to me that, regardless of whatever IP agreements you've made, some will obviously be trying to build stuff they can reuse elsewhere. It's hard to enforce an IP agreement when you're in Boston and they're a couple continents away.
Re:Ask HN: Why don't startups outsource/offshore development...
by notahacker on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @10:12AM
(#9062599)
Legal threats against ex-employees based in your home country carry an awful lot more weight than legal threats against a subcontractor based in India, Russia or China.
Re:Ask HN: Why don't startups outsource/offshore development...
by logfromblammo on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @11:30AM
(#9063121)
And, surely, they will honor their contracts to the letter.
Your employees might take home your entire code base in the US, while working on-site on an air-gapped network. They can certainly do it when you're set up for remote work, almost by definition. In the US, the payoff for stealing your employer's code is low, and the risk of punishment high, but it still happens. I can't speak for non-US countries, but I would guess that most have a bit more relaxed attitude toward enforcement, especially when it would be on behalf of a US company.
If you think your IP is secure from the software developers who wrote it, you do not understand how they work. If you do not hold the loyalty of your developers, you do not control the IP, regardless of what the contracts say.
As for the quality of developers, you will find everything across the board. The best shops in India are process driven and serious about continuous improvement and can be a joy to work with. The dirty little secret of IBM Watson and other commercial NLP systems is that it takes a small army to code those kind of things and you can get the manpower there.
I think the #1 fear about a tech company outsourcing is that you don't really control the intellectual property. This might not matter so much if you are running a two-sided market (Uber could outsource development because anybody who wants to rip them off has to go fight city hall in thousands of places) but if you really are a "tech" company you want to keep your knowledge close.