Section 399.88(a) states that it is an unfair and deceptive practice for any seller of scheduled air transportation within, to, or from the United States, or of a tour or tour component that includes scheduled air transportation within, to, or from the United States, to increase the price of that air transportation to a consumer after the air transportation has been purchased by the consumer [...] even when the fare is a “mistake.”
This is done specifically in case an airline decides to publish a $1 transpacific business class sale, too many people jump on, and then the airline retroactively decides the price was too good and voids peoples tickets out or comes knocking for more money.
It will be interesting to see which side the DOT takes this time around.
Re:United Airlines: A first-class cock up
by coldcode on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @12:05PM
(#9063399)
If the bookings were on United's website (it doesn't say exactly) then they should be liable regardless of how it got that way. If the bookings were on another website then the DOT will likely agree with United. Having worked for a large travel OTA, the rules for the taker of money are different than for a third party who only collects the data but not the money.
Re:United Airlines: A first-class cock up
by arcticbull on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @12:13PM
(#9063465)
I think you're conflating consolidator/unpublished fares with published fares. These were all published fares. Even OTAs have the plating carrier collect the money on published fares. Either way, point of sale doesn't matter for DOT to apply, just that you're flying to or from the US.
Re:United Airlines: A first-class cock up
by Someone1234 on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @10:58AM
(#9062884)
> “And even more so it is not fair to revoke the tickets that were already purchased.”
I'm always amused when people whine that a company didn't honour an OBVIOUS pricing error. It is one thing if the price was 10% off, but in this case it is like a 90% reduction if not more (depending on which first class fare class the tickets were in, £52 instead of £1000-1500).
The only thing I will add as far as fairness goes, is that customers are often held to a different standard. If a customer makes a mistake in their booking, they have approx. 24 hours to fix it for "free." If a company makes a mistake they often have near unlimited time to fix it (until check-in?).
But as far as cancelling mistakes in general? I have much more sympathy when the company takes too long to do so, or the pricing error is more subtle than in this case.
Re:United Airlines: A first-class cock up
by logfromblammo on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @01:59PM
(#9064228)
Airlines are hoist on their own petard in this case. Given the complexity of airline fare pricing, nothing is obvious. Nothing.
I would not be surprised in the least if they charged left-handed customers 1% more than right-handed customers.
If Wal-Mart sold a $300 television set for $3, I could see a case for OBVIOUS pricing error. Wal-Mart has a consistent pricing policy, wherein the price is the same for anyone who walks into the store, and clearly printed on the shelf label.
Not so for airlines. A typical airline flight could have dozens of fare classes, and any given seat on it could be mapped to multiple fare classes. If someone buys a "K" fare, they get seat 14B. Now if someone tries to get a "Q" fare with their loyalty points, the flight is sold out, because "Q" fares are only good for row 14 on that flight. Later, the "K" fare cancels for only a partial refund, and someone pays quadruple the price for a "G" fare and gets exactly the same seat, but their fare is fully refundable. If you walked onto the plane and pointed at seat 14B, and asked airline personnel how much it would cost to sit there for that flight, not a single one of them could tell you. It doesn't work that way.
So if they made a "mistake", then too fucking bad. Honor the fare you sold, you bastards, because our patience with your price discrimination games was already at an end 10 years ago.
Re:United Airlines: A first-class cock up
by mikeash on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @11:26AM
(#9063104)
Regarding fairness over customer mistakes, I experienced one recently that impressed me greatly (albeit unrelated to airlines). I bought a house two years ago and recently discovered that I never cancelled my insurance for the condo that I sold shortly afterwards. The house insurance was rolled into my mortgage whereas the condo insurance was deducted from my bank account, so I didn't notice the double payment for a long time because they weren't in the same place.
When I called to cancel the condo insurance, they offered, without any prompting on my part, to refund all of the excess premium payments after the sale, even though it was nearly two years ago at this point.
Many companies will actually make good on an honest mistake like this.
Edit: another example just occurred to me. There are frequent stories about people running up bills on Amazon Web Services (and sometimes other cloud providers) by accident, typically because their servers got compromised or their credentials leaked. The provider typically credits the excess.
Re:United Airlines: A first-class cock up
by praneshp on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @02:31PM
(#9064426)
I have only good things to say about AWS. I once got $2500 of credit from them for a research grant, and left the servers running after the project ended and ran up about $600 extra. At this point, I was no longer in the lab, but still a student and had no way to pay an extra $600. AWS wrote off the entire cost, despite this being totally my mistake.
Re:United Airlines: A first-class cock up
by spydum on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @02:08PM
(#9064285)
To be fair, in your example as long as you didn't make any claims during that period, the cost to them was next to nothing (maybe some stamps for mail? couple cents for your share of the automated billing processing).
Re:United Airlines: A first-class cock up
by saganus on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @11:19AM
(#9063045)
The problem is that the line where the "obvious" starts is not so obvious.
For example, in Mexico there's a law that basically states that a price published is a valid price and as a seller you have to honor that price regardless of how low or absurd it might be. There has been several cases where this has been upheld where you could argue that it was "obvious", e.g., a TV (recent model) sold for like $4 USD.
However I believe it is way easier to just establish a "simple" law such as that one, than trying to define what obvious means and what doesn't.
I also remember someone explaining me (not sure if this was the real reason or not, but sounds sensible), that it was also to protect from bait and switch scams, where a seller would say such-and-such items sold at X price, really cheap so people would come, and then saying, oh no, it's just an error, it's actually 5X the price. And so the consumer is protected, or at least that's the idea.
Re:United Airlines: A first-class cock up
by mseebach on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @11:33AM
(#9063138)
Most of the time, there's little recourse from pricing mistakes, exactly for the reasons you mention - but there is usually (and definitely in this case - can't speak for Mexico) an exception for entering the contract in bad faith.
From the article: “The traditional rule at common law,” says Peter Cartwright, a professor of consumer law at Nottingham University, “is that if one party has made a mistake as to the terms of the contract and the other party knows of that mistake, the contract is not binding.”
The burden of proof is on the company, and anyone who were in good faith can sue United for breach of contract. But they better have a good explanation for why they suddenly decided to browse for airfares in Danish kroner.
Re:United Airlines: A first-class cock up
by nimblegorilla on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @11:14AM
(#9062997)
> an OBVIOUS pricing error
How does the average person know when something is an obvious error? Pilots and other airline personnel often fly standby at ridiculously cheap rates. Sometimes airlines fly planes almost completely empty:
http://www.cnn.com/2015/01/13/travel/man-alone-delta-flight-...
It seems plausible that United could offer extreme discounts for some unknown reason.
Re:United Airlines: A first-class cock up
by reverend_gonzo on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @11:19AM
(#9063043)
When you can buy something at a 90% discount that is at an unadvertised price by buying it in a different currency than it was quoted, it should be completely obvious that it is a pricing error.
As for pilots flying standby, it's a perk of being an employee in the industry. Every single industry has perks for those within it.
Re:United Airlines: A first-class cock up
by rbcgerard on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @12:32PM
(#9063611)
Actually there can be significant pricing differentials based on the country of purchase (which is done ON PURPOSE by the airlines) - for example usually LAN is much cheaper to book via their Chliean website then via the US website...
Re:United Airlines: A first-class cock up
by Someone1234 on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @11:47AM
(#9063240)
Just as background:
This error didn't occur if you booked from Denmark. You had to book via the UK website but in Danish Kroner. The actual Danish site (which uses Danish Kroner) had the correct price.
Re:United Airlines: A first-class cock up
by mikeash on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @11:20AM
(#9063050)
Can you honestly say that you'd go to an airline's web site, search for a flight, get quoted a price, notice that if you switch to a foreign currency the quoted price is literally 100x cheaper, and think it's probably legitimate?
If you'd actually think that, I'd say you're probably not safe to have out in public without an escort.
Re:United Airlines: A first-class cock up
by zhte415 on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @12:47PM
(#9063730)
Yes, yes you can. Easyjet / Ryanair / other low cost European carrier pricing policies were extremely predatory for years, in completely arbitrary ways.
Re:United Airlines: A first-class cock up
by mseebach on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @11:14AM
(#9063006)
> customers are often held to a different standard
Are they really? Do we have a lot of data on what happens when customers make booking mistakes that the airline should objectively have realised is a mistake?
The closest thing I have to a datapoint is that my company once booked me on a flight on a fare that should have cost ~£800 but was quoted and paid >£3k (I flagged it but the travel office didn't seem to care and I certainly had better things to do with my time). I was upgraded to business class on check in, that's never happened before or since, and I travel quite a lot.
Re:United Airlines: A first-class cock up
by rbcgerard on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @12:37PM
(#9063655)
of course they are - essentially United's defense is that someone "fat fingered" the exchange rate...if I were to make the same mistake with regards to my dates of travel or flight times etc. I have 24hrs (with UA) to make a change - otherwise I have to pay for my mistake...Which i suppose begs the question of how quickly UA canceled the fares
Re:United Airlines: A first-class cock up
by rbcgerard on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @12:30PM
(#9063593)
Airlines (maybe not UA) often sell super cheap tickets (spirit, southwest, ryanair) so its not like its not without precedent - so while its likely people knew it was an error, they have some cover, I mean how would you know conclusively its not?
Re:United Airlines: A first-class cock up
by discardorama on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @11:20AM
(#9063053)
Talking about switched prices: I read recently about Amazon and Squaretrade. Apparently, Amazon pulls in the Squaretrade warranty price dynamically when it renders the page for an item; and Squaretrade uses some sophisticated model to determine the price. So if you add it to your cart when you're buying the item, you are not guaranteed to get the same price you saw; the price of the warranty in the cart can often be much higher.
Re:United Airlines: A first-class cock up
by Someone1234 on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @11:56AM
(#9063314)
That's pretty damn shady if true.
Also likely illegal in Europe at least. There have been cases of prices magically increasing as items are moved to the cart/checkout, and companies have been fined (see EasyJet for one example).
Re:United Airlines: A first-class cock up
by Jolijn on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @12:03PM
(#9063384)
I've had this with orders on Amazon in the past year or so, though every time in my favor. I mean, it's a nice surprise to end up paying 10% to 15% less than your were ready for, but I am always puzzled WHY exactly I have been chosen as the recipient of this kindness.
Re:United Airlines: A first-class cock up
by maxmcd on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @11:02AM
(#9062913)
Airlines make less than a dollar per traveler per flight correct? They expect little year-over-year growth, and likely see little more than the baseline return on their marketing spend.
If that's their worldview, I can't see how they would ever justify such a large comparative loss for a little PR bump.
Re:United Airlines: A first-class cock up
by arcticbull on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @12:08PM
(#9063423)
That's after losing $500 Million in Q1 2014. You've cherry picked a very, very good year for airlines with low capacity, strong demand and low oil prices. It's a highly cyclic and usually difficult business to be in.
However, I believe the commenter said airlines, not United in particular. IATA published a 2013 report indicating that in fact airlines worldwide in aggregate made $4 net per passenger per segment.
Re:United Airlines: A first-class cock up
by mikeash on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @11:00AM
(#9062901)
I can't believe that people are so shameless that they will actually complain when they attempt to rip off a company and their trick is discovered. I can kind of sort of understand making the attempt in the first place, but surely one should have enough human decency to let it go once you get caught.
Edit: the points history on this comment is interesting so far. Up, then quite a bit down. I wonder what you're downvoting. Do you just dislike the straightforward language of calling a spade a spade? Do you actually somehow think that it's OK to rip off a company like this?
Re:United Airlines: A first-class cock up
by spiritplumber on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @11:20AM
(#9063049)
When the cable or water company does it to me (overcharging on a bill), it takes months to get solved, and they make you feel like you're trying to rip them off, so, no - it has to go both ways or none.
(Cue me last year walking into a Comcast office with my lawyer in tow to discuss them charging me a modem rental fee whereas I have my own modem - in truth, we just were in the neighborhood)
Re:United Airlines: A first-class cock up
by mikeash on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @12:37PM
(#9063657)
Interesting how both replies at the moment espouse the idea that it's OK to rip them off because sometimes they rip us off. This sentiment is disturbingly common!
Re:United Airlines: A first-class cock up
by dandandan on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @12:43PM
(#9063711)
It's not entirely unreasonable that a fare would be priced lower in another currency / country. Try booking a flight from LHR - JFK in GBP and USD in the UK and the US and tell me if the amounts correspond at all.
http://airconsumer.dot.gov/rules/EAPP_2_FAQ_01-11-2012final....
Section 399.88(a) states that it is an unfair and deceptive practice for any seller of scheduled air transportation within, to, or from the United States, or of a tour or tour component that includes scheduled air transportation within, to, or from the United States, to increase the price of that air transportation to a consumer after the air transportation has been purchased by the consumer [...] even when the fare is a “mistake.”
This is done specifically in case an airline decides to publish a $1 transpacific business class sale, too many people jump on, and then the airline retroactively decides the price was too good and voids peoples tickets out or comes knocking for more money.
It will be interesting to see which side the DOT takes this time around.
I'm always amused when people whine that a company didn't honour an OBVIOUS pricing error. It is one thing if the price was 10% off, but in this case it is like a 90% reduction if not more (depending on which first class fare class the tickets were in, £52 instead of £1000-1500).
The only thing I will add as far as fairness goes, is that customers are often held to a different standard. If a customer makes a mistake in their booking, they have approx. 24 hours to fix it for "free." If a company makes a mistake they often have near unlimited time to fix it (until check-in?).
But as far as cancelling mistakes in general? I have much more sympathy when the company takes too long to do so, or the pricing error is more subtle than in this case.
I would not be surprised in the least if they charged left-handed customers 1% more than right-handed customers.
If Wal-Mart sold a $300 television set for $3, I could see a case for OBVIOUS pricing error. Wal-Mart has a consistent pricing policy, wherein the price is the same for anyone who walks into the store, and clearly printed on the shelf label.
Not so for airlines. A typical airline flight could have dozens of fare classes, and any given seat on it could be mapped to multiple fare classes. If someone buys a "K" fare, they get seat 14B. Now if someone tries to get a "Q" fare with their loyalty points, the flight is sold out, because "Q" fares are only good for row 14 on that flight. Later, the "K" fare cancels for only a partial refund, and someone pays quadruple the price for a "G" fare and gets exactly the same seat, but their fare is fully refundable. If you walked onto the plane and pointed at seat 14B, and asked airline personnel how much it would cost to sit there for that flight, not a single one of them could tell you. It doesn't work that way.
So if they made a "mistake", then too fucking bad. Honor the fare you sold, you bastards, because our patience with your price discrimination games was already at an end 10 years ago.
When I called to cancel the condo insurance, they offered, without any prompting on my part, to refund all of the excess premium payments after the sale, even though it was nearly two years ago at this point.
Many companies will actually make good on an honest mistake like this.
Edit: another example just occurred to me. There are frequent stories about people running up bills on Amazon Web Services (and sometimes other cloud providers) by accident, typically because their servers got compromised or their credentials leaked. The provider typically credits the excess.
For example, in Mexico there's a law that basically states that a price published is a valid price and as a seller you have to honor that price regardless of how low or absurd it might be. There has been several cases where this has been upheld where you could argue that it was "obvious", e.g., a TV (recent model) sold for like $4 USD.
However I believe it is way easier to just establish a "simple" law such as that one, than trying to define what obvious means and what doesn't.
I also remember someone explaining me (not sure if this was the real reason or not, but sounds sensible), that it was also to protect from bait and switch scams, where a seller would say such-and-such items sold at X price, really cheap so people would come, and then saying, oh no, it's just an error, it's actually 5X the price. And so the consumer is protected, or at least that's the idea.
From the article: “The traditional rule at common law,” says Peter Cartwright, a professor of consumer law at Nottingham University, “is that if one party has made a mistake as to the terms of the contract and the other party knows of that mistake, the contract is not binding.”
The burden of proof is on the company, and anyone who were in good faith can sue United for breach of contract. But they better have a good explanation for why they suddenly decided to browse for airfares in Danish kroner.
How does the average person know when something is an obvious error? Pilots and other airline personnel often fly standby at ridiculously cheap rates. Sometimes airlines fly planes almost completely empty: http://www.cnn.com/2015/01/13/travel/man-alone-delta-flight-...
It seems plausible that United could offer extreme discounts for some unknown reason.
As for pilots flying standby, it's a perk of being an employee in the industry. Every single industry has perks for those within it.
I might have thought it was a pricing error or I might have thought it was some sort of bizarre Danish Groupon-esque marketing ploy.
bookingbuddy.com is currently advertising 80% off sales. I don't see how 90% becomes unreasonable compared to that.
2) Booking buddy is advertising the sale.
3) "Bizarre Groupon-esque marketing ploy" depends on marketing.
Companies don't intentionally, and without advertising, discount shit for 90% off, but only when you find a backdoor method to get there.
You're either really grasping at straws to legitimize this, or you're completely clueless about how the world works.
Anyone booking the fare from Denmark has a case here, everyone else don't.
This error didn't occur if you booked from Denmark. You had to book via the UK website but in Danish Kroner. The actual Danish site (which uses Danish Kroner) had the correct price.
If you'd actually think that, I'd say you're probably not safe to have out in public without an escort.
Are they really? Do we have a lot of data on what happens when customers make booking mistakes that the airline should objectively have realised is a mistake?
The closest thing I have to a datapoint is that my company once booked me on a flight on a fare that should have cost ~£800 but was quoted and paid >£3k (I flagged it but the travel office didn't seem to care and I certainly had better things to do with my time). I was upgraded to business class on check in, that's never happened before or since, and I travel quite a lot.
Also likely illegal in Europe at least. There have been cases of prices magically increasing as items are moved to the cart/checkout, and companies have been fined (see EasyJet for one example).
Seems like a legit case of bait-n-switch to me. Granted, it's not a lot of money, but still something to lookout for.
That's really shady.
If that's their worldview, I can't see how they would ever justify such a large comparative loss for a little PR bump.
No, that is wrong. Very wrong.
United: $1.13 Billion Profit 2014
The so-called ancillary revenue alone — fees for everything from checking a bag to more legroom — amounts to more than $22 per passenger.
However, I believe the commenter said airlines, not United in particular. IATA published a 2013 report indicating that in fact airlines worldwide in aggregate made $4 net per passenger per segment.
http://www.iata.org/pressroom/pr/Pages/2013-06-03-02.aspx
If they do indeed make more than $22 per passenger on ancillary revenue, that means they loose $14 per passenger if you look at the fare in isolation.
Edit: NY to London is actually 2x distance between London and Athens
Edit: the points history on this comment is interesting so far. Up, then quite a bit down. I wonder what you're downvoting. Do you just dislike the straightforward language of calling a spade a spade? Do you actually somehow think that it's OK to rip off a company like this?
(Cue me last year walking into a Comcast office with my lawyer in tow to discuss them charging me a modem rental fee whereas I have my own modem - in truth, we just were in the neighborhood)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clean_hands
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_pari_delicto
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nemo_auditur_propriam_turpitudi...
The latter can, for instance, be invoked when a thief complains that someone stole stolen goods from him.
When you are operating in a court of equity rather than a court of law, the judge has greater latitude to consider what would be a just remedy.
Airlines price discriminate a ton, but they don't sell trans-Atlantic first-class seats for $80.