Re:When Grandmasters Blunder: Even the best make mistakes
by rockdoe on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @06:53AM
(#9061706)
Your response has absolutely nothing to do with the point the parent poster makes and completely and utterly misses the point.
He is arguing that "percentage of winning" is not linearly related to "pawn or equivalent advantage". That has got nothing to do with whether those pawns are physical ones or positional advantages that have equivalent value.
Re:When Grandmasters Blunder: Even the best make mistakes
by dfan on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @07:45AM
(#9061890)
Yes, I know how computer evaluations work. The fact that they take positional as well as material considerations into play doesn't change the point, which is that playing a +5 sure-win move instead of a +8 sure-win move is not a horrific magnitude-3 blunder the way that playing a -2 move instead of a +1 move is, whatever your units of magnitude are, because what really matters is the change in the expected result of the game.
Chess engines also implement a heuristic called 'contempt' where they may make a sacrifice in order to avoid a drawn position, when faced with an inferior opponent.