News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Thoughts on Rich Hickey's advice on becoming a be... by btilly on Monday February 16, 2015 @04:23PM (#9059124)
Both are right, and they agree with each other. But you have to understand what they are talking about to get it.

The point of Peter Norvig's advice is that once one has learned 3 different ways to do one thing, it is easier to abstract out the fundamental principles and think about when to take one approach or another. Which makes it easier to understand the actual game.

Which leads into Rich Hickey's advice. Recognize that the game you are in is programming. Which is the art of keeping software doing what we want to it to subject to various constraints including timelines, changing requirements, and so on. This is not the accumulation of esoteric information. This is not the accumulation of prebuilt solutions. Those are necessary, but not sufficient. You need both a skill set and a mind set.

I used to like chess so I'll use a chess analogy. In chess, and many other games, there is a clear difference between tactics and strategy. Tactics is, "I do this, he does that, I respond like so..." Strategy is the abstraction across tactical situations to recognize things like the importance of controlling the center, that attacks naturally proceed along the line of pawn chains, and what affects the relative value of pieces in different situations.

You cannot learn strategy without knowing tactics. Because the accumulation of strategic advantages is useless without the tactical skills to notice and use the opportunities that arise. And mumbled slogans do not a coherent strategy make. So learn tactics first. But to become a great chess player, you will need to master strategy.

The same applies to programming. Programming tactics include languages, paradigms, platforms, building blocks, open source, conferences etc. These do not constitute strategy. Learn strategy. But you cannot do that without learning programming tactics first.

Re:Ask HN: Thoughts on Rich Hickey's advice on becoming a be... by e12e on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @01:27AM (#9060939)
I like that: strategy enables tactics. Much like logistics enables strategy.