Re:Plan to Stop Rhino Poaching by Growing Horns in a Lab
by gus_massa on Monday February 16, 2015 @11:00AM
(#9057451)
I wish this idea works. The problem is that the main cause of rhino horn use is magical thinking (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rhinoceros#Horn_trade_and_use), but I suppose you can't grow the magic part in the lab and the users will want the real thing.
It's similar to the jewelry use of diamonds. You can create artificial diamonds in the laboratory, they are cheaper and they are used a lot in industrial applications (maybe they are better because you can control the impurities?). But for jewelry the people wants the real diamonds because they apparently have some kind of magic.
Re:Plan to Stop Rhino Poaching by Growing Horns in a Lab
by lkbm on Monday February 16, 2015 @01:06PM
(#9058184)
On the other hand, with diamonds, I'm guessing there are regulations ensuring synthetic diamonds are labelled differently from natural. With natural horns being illegal, who's going to know?
This might be harder for authorities to identify real horn products, but it'll also make it harder for consumers.
Hopefully the authorities don't decide to solve the former problem with some sort of certification that can also be used to solve the latter.
Re:Plan to Stop Rhino Poaching by Growing Horns in a Lab
by xkcd-sucks on Saturday February 21, 2015 @11:47PM
(#9088265)
The first few google hits suggest that current fakes are made of resin, etc. with some frog meat thrown in for scent. So they're not so expensive that people don't sell whole horns, unless they're all fake
It's similar to the jewelry use of diamonds. You can create artificial diamonds in the laboratory, they are cheaper and they are used a lot in industrial applications (maybe they are better because you can control the impurities?). But for jewelry the people wants the real diamonds because they apparently have some kind of magic.
This might be harder for authorities to identify real horn products, but it'll also make it harder for consumers.
Hopefully the authorities don't decide to solve the former problem with some sort of certification that can also be used to solve the latter.
It's essentially just keratin, which can be reclaimed from hair and nail clippings.
Most people don't buy entire horns, as the price is really high ($50k-100k/kg according to google).
Keratin powder, or keratin pressed into chunks, would probably fool most people, and there's effectively no way for consumers to verify authenticity.
So, fake rhino horn is easier than fake drugs, fake gemstones, fake currency etc.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8248874