News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Quantum Physics and the Abuse of Reason by VLM on Sunday February 15, 2015 @04:04PM (#9054123)
When a physicist speculates, and someone points out that implies a sign reversal in ohms law, "oh well, I'll try again later". There's an immense collection of constraints based on experimental results that they try to respect.

When a philosopher speculates, and someone points out a problem with the theory, welcome to the wonderful world of sophistry and logical fallacy, would you like your ad hominem attack flame merely well done or extra crispy? Usually with a trendy side dish of political correctness and authoritarianism. Not to mention the typical attitude of "experimental results, who needs em?"

Re:Quantum Physics and the Abuse of Reason by foldr on Sunday February 15, 2015 @04:37PM (#9054231)
>When a physicist speculates..there's an immense collection of constraints based on experimental results that they try to respect.

No, not really. See e.g. Krauss's speculations that I mentioned above.

What you say about philosophy is just a caricature. At least point to specific philosophers or specific articles.