News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by meesterdude on Sunday February 15, 2015 @06:32AM (#9052367)
I skimmed the first quarter of it and read through the rest; a decent read that touches on a lot of good points.

I found this particularly interesting:

The mistake of many modern feminists, he writes, is that they “look only at the top of society and draw conclusions about society as a whole. Yes, there are mostly men at the top. But if you look at the bottom, really at the bottom, you’ll find mostly men there, too.” His examples: The homeless; the imprisoned; the people who die at work, 92 percent of whom are male. The popular modern view is that it’s women who are most poorly valued by culture. But, ever the contrarian, Baumeister says men are demonstrably “more expendable than women.”

Also this:

Susan remembers hearing about a theory that the most successful people in life are those who are still searching for their parents’ unconditional regard.

Sound like any famous (recently deceased) CEO?

Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by erikb on Sunday February 15, 2015 @08:03AM (#9052497)
The idea that men are on the top and the bottom and women somewhere in the middle is something I also experienced when learning about China. There are so many men who are completely unable to find a decent job and nor any wife at all, and on the other end of the spectrum men so rich that one of them has more money/power than a small country. The point that women completely ignore the men on the bottom and fight each other about the men on the top, who in turn have so much choice and so little punishment for bad behaviour that they don't regard women as breathing human beings, seems to add up to a picture that looks quite realistic.

It's probably a little too simplified, though. While the percentages vary between top and bottom men and women, you have both on each level. Beside the amount of people one would also need to look at the impact on each gender's life. And the result might still be that a woman on the bottom might have a much harder life than a man, and a woman at the top might not gain as many rewards as a man.

It's rather hard to get a complete picture, right?

Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by Tycho on Sunday February 15, 2015 @10:12AM (#9052783)
I've never seen those two ideas combined before: the skewness of the male population towards failure, and the resulting misogyny of the "spoilt for choice" men at the other end of the distribution. Very interesting.
Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by saraid216 on Sunday February 15, 2015 @02:08PM (#9053632)
Notably, the men at the bottom are considered failures for failing to acquire a wife. That's also one of those things that feminism takes issue with. Poor males are not saints; they just aren't in a position to actually change the overall status quo.

If wife acquisition stopped being an indicator of success in China, you'd have a lot fewer men being considered at the bottom.

Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by alextgordon on Sunday February 15, 2015 @02:43PM (#9053767)
Wife acquisition will continue to be a measure of success so long as China's sex ratio at birth is 1.1 men to every woman.

No wife means not only a lonely existence, but also no children to care for you in your old age. If that isn't failure, I don't know what is.

Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by Omniusaspirer on Sunday February 15, 2015 @07:04PM (#9054699)
>No wife means not only a lonely existence, but also no children to care for you in your old age. If that isn't failure, I don't know what is.

This line of thinking just seems juvenile to me. Do you really believe the pinnacle of human achievement (and the only one that matters) is being in a long term relationship and having children?

Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by wtbob on Sunday February 15, 2015 @09:30PM (#9055055)
> Do you really believe the pinnacle of human achievement (and the only one that matters) is being in a long term relationship and having children?

Can anyone with any sense of Darwinian evolution not believe that having children is the goal of life? Can anyone with any emotional sense at all not believe that a lasting relationship with another is not the highest of pursuits?

Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by saraid216 on Sunday February 15, 2015 @09:38PM (#9055075)
Yes and yes.

I'm personally far more interested in passing down a cultural legacy than squirting my genes into an egg, and I'm more inclined towards raising the average happiness of the world than just a single relationship.

The funny thing about belief is that it doesn't necessarily extend from basic facts like having read the same book.

Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by Omniusaspirer on Monday February 16, 2015 @01:00AM (#9055541)
Darwinian evolution is useless when applied to modern humanity. There is no "survival of the fittest". Consider also that individual genetics are irrelevant to breeding success when put against external factors like security and wealth. Our knowledge and ideas are much more valuable to humanities survival than our individual genetics at this point.

I would also personally argue that once you gain the ability to modify the human genome any desire for classical evolution is deeply flawed. Relationships are largely a holdover from the evolutionary need to reproduce, although obviously it's good for our happiness and emotional state to satisfy those desires in our current form.

Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by EliRivers on Monday February 16, 2015 @07:21AM (#9056536)
Can anyone with any sense of Darwinian evolution not believe that having children is the goal of life?

I can. Life doesn't have a goal. It's not some kind of plan. It just happens.

Can anyone with any emotional sense at all not believe that a lasting relationship with another is not the highest of pursuits?

I can. A lasting relationship with another? A fucking guinea pig can do that. Humans are capable of so much more.

Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by saraid216 on Sunday February 15, 2015 @09:05PM (#9054987)
You're actually giving him too much credit. Speaking as someone whose family has the same values, "having children" isn't enough. They have to be obedient and willing to care for you in your old age. Success, in these terms, is breeding future slaves for your twilight years. The academic term for this is "filial piety". It also includes things like guilting your children for all the things you forced them into doing, such as learning the violin or piano.

To state the obvious, I am kinda disagreeable to this presumption.

Similarly, he's not just talking about a "long term relationship", but a much more economic arrangement where one's wife fulfills your needs for companionship and breeding in return for the bread you win. Unsurprisingly, this is something that many modern Chinese women have started balking at.

Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by erikb on Sunday February 15, 2015 @02:35PM (#9053734)
That's an interesting view. My English is not so good. What I meant was that getting a wife is the result of being successful for the Chinese guys I know. If you have a stable job, an apartment and a car you are quite likely to get a wife. But there are many people applying for the jobs, and cars/apartments are more expensive than in the west.

Or was your comment linked to that in some way?

Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by saraid216 on Sunday February 15, 2015 @09:29PM (#9055049)
That isn't congruous to what I know.

From what I've seen and heard, getting a wife was the goal, and since women had actual choices, they'd be choosing someone with a stable job, apartment, etc., so the men feel compelled to get those things. They're not accidentally tripping over wives; they're actively seeking them out.

Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by erikb on Monday February 16, 2015 @02:18PM (#9058638)
That's interesting. From what I've seen I would guess that Chinese women seek marriage partners above else, but Chinese men choose financial success above else. Losing a wife to get rich is okay for them. But failing to get a car and house can not be compensated by having a wife.

I would agree that marriage is more important to Chinese men than to western men. The idea of marriage is also different, though.

Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by rlthomas on Sunday February 15, 2015 @06:43PM (#9054661)
The root of this is that having a daughter was less culturally valued, people chose sex-selective abortions (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sex-selective_abortion#China), which led to a skewed gender ratio for the population. Many rural men struggle to find wives because of the shortage. If women/daughters were more valued, there would be more women, and poor men would have an easier time finding a wife. So even though there are more men on the bottom, it was caused by valuing men over women.
Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by rlthomas on Sunday February 15, 2015 @02:34PM (#9053730)
I think a large part of the reason that men are more likely to end up "on the bottom" of society is that men have smaller support systems/friend networks than women. Some of the reasons for this are stigma against men expressing vulnerability, stigma against men seeking help, homophobia around close male friendships, gender expectations that women should do more "emotional work" than men, and stereotypes that women are social and men are not. Feminism seeks to dismantle all of the above, so in that sense, it would make it possible for men to have much stronger support networks.

Additionally, many (most?) feminists believe in "intersectionality", the belief that sexism, racism, classism, ableism, and heterosexism act in intersecting ways, and that all need to be dismantled together (for instance, this is why most feminists support reform of the US prison system, even though this is something that primarily effects men). Dismantling these oppressive systems would very much help those on the bottom.

The exclusive-focus-on-more-white-woman-as-CEOs brand of feminism is actually a minority of feminists (although they seem to get the most coverage in the popular press) and is widely critiqued within feminism.

Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by ZenoArrow on Sunday February 15, 2015 @03:48PM (#9054046)
> "Additionally, many (most?) feminists believe in "intersectionality", the belief that sexism, racism, classism, ableism, and heterosexism act in intersecting ways"

Yes, of course they intersect, at their core they're all the same thing; judgements made based on human traits.

What does it matter whether people are judged based on gender, skin colour, etc... ? The point is, the judgements are being made whilst we build a picture of the world around us. The danger only comes when irrational traits are associated, when those being judged are not careful about self-fulfilling prophecies, and when people forget that stereotypes are a shortcut, never the whole picture.

Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by saraid216 on Sunday February 15, 2015 @09:35PM (#9055064)
While I was going to tell you to look up the term "kyriarchy", I decided to verify my spelling and instead found this write-up:

https://rancom.wordpress.com/2010/10/01/why-no-one-should-us...

It has the double-barreled utility of both sufficiently explaining the term I wanted to introduce to you and provide a reasonable critique of it at the same time.

Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by onnoonno on Monday February 16, 2015 @05:10AM (#9056098)
Yet it seems to be feminism that clouds the mind by being everything and all at the same time, with about 1000 different subtypes and OF COURSE you are following the right ones.

How about we drop that stupid feminism label and movement and start to actually talk about the issues at hand?

Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by saturnine on Sunday February 15, 2015 @02:47PM (#9053781)
"[T]here are mostly men at the top [and] at the bottom"

That's consistent with analysis by Howard Wainer[1] on gender differences:

"[I]t has been well established that there is an overabundance of boys at the high end of test score distributions. [S]ome observers have used such results to make inferences about differences in intelligence between the sexes. [H]owever, most enlightened investigators have seen that it is not necessarily a difference in level but a difference in variance that separates the sexes. Thus, while there are more boys at the high end, there are also more at the low end."

[1] The Most Dangerous Equation http://press.princeton.edu/chapters/s8863.pdf

Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by facepalm on Sunday February 15, 2015 @04:29PM (#9054205)
Here is a transcript of a speech he gave on the subject of men: http://triggeralert.blogspot.de/2010/10/is-there-anything-go... I think it's well worth a read.
Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by leoc on Sunday February 15, 2015 @09:15AM (#9052636)
> Susan remembers hearing about a theory that the most successful people in life are those who are still searching for their parents’ unconditional regard.

BBC correspondent Robert Peston made a short radio documentary http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b00nh06m about this after being left with the same impression after interviewing many successful business people as part of his job. There's also the idea that the experience of an (in some way) absent parent during childhood is strongly correlated with narcissism, which in turn is strongly correlated with success in the entertainment industry. (I can't find a good link which discusses this atm.)

Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by geogra4 on Sunday February 15, 2015 @11:23AM (#9053009)
>The mistake of many modern feminists, he writes, is that they “look only at the top of society and draw conclusions about society as a whole

This is a critique that a lot of feminists make as well. Google the phrase 'white feminism' to see

Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by barry-cotter on Sunday February 15, 2015 @09:06PM (#9054989)
>Susan remembers hearing about a theory that the most successful people in life are those who are still searching for their parents’ unconditional regard. Sound like any famous (recently deceased) CEO?

If this is a reference to Steve Jobs it arguues with great strength against your point. Jobs was raised by a working class couple who adopted him. From reading Isaacson's biography they seem to have been proud but bemused parents. Comparing Jobs to his biological sister (His grad student parents later married and had her.) and his adoptive sister would suggest heredity is pretty powerful.

Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by maaaats on Sunday February 15, 2015 @07:04AM (#9052406)
> a decent read that touches on a lot of good points.

Too bad the title is really off-putting. Sounds like any clickbait website, not a good journalistic piece.

Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by meesterdude on Sunday February 15, 2015 @07:22AM (#9052419)
thats why i skimmed the first quarter of it :)
Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by adekok on Sunday February 15, 2015 @09:14AM (#9052634)
> The mistake of many modern feminists, he writes, is that they “look only at the top of society..."

And see themselves as deserving of the same. As entitled to it. Without doing the 20 years of 16 hour days which helped the CEO get there.

There's a large amount of narcissism in such declarations.

Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by A_COMPUTER on Sunday February 15, 2015 @12:05PM (#9053177)
His criticism of feminism is terrible and nothing new at all. I wish he would just shut up and try to draw inferences from his data instead of speculating on a movement he hasn't made any actual attempts to understand. Feminism deserves competent critique from outside its own movement, but it's sure not coming from him. Feminism has more than enough explanation for the expendability of males, he just doesn't know that because he's working from a caricature.
Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by graeme on Sunday February 15, 2015 @12:11PM (#9053211)
Could you link a feminist discussion of the expendibility of males, skewness of male outcomes, or a critique of Baumeister? I read Baumeister's essay a little while ago, and went looking for critiques. All I found was name calling. I'd like to read an actual response.

(for anyone reading, I'm actually very interested in reading a critique. I'm not just passively calling out the parent post.)

Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by A_COMPUTER on Sunday February 15, 2015 @12:56PM (#9053346)
I don't have any offhand but let me give you one. The social construction of "men" is that men are made (this is in contrast to social construction of women as natural e.g. babymakers.) You have to work to be a man, you don't have innate value. To be a man you compete with other males for resources and reputation. This is the basis of hierarchy, part of male society, the so-called Patriarchy. In competition there are of course losers. They are not men, so much as they are failed men. This is a natural state, there are winners and losers in life. So the theory goes, feminism wants to free men from this destructive social order. This is a feminist theory that explains why there are men on the top and men on the bottom but masculinity is still the underlying principle.

That is one theory, there are other theories. You can poke holes in this theory, but it's not just a handwave that feminists haven't thought about this or recognized that men are disposable. I mean, feminism knows about this thing called "war." My major problem with feminism is that there is a large gap between theory and activism which results in time and energy being spent on CEO equality and ignoring feminism's own arguments about how mistreated many males are in the lower rungs of society. But that is a problem with practice, not theory.

Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by graeme on Sunday February 15, 2015 @01:24PM (#9053449)
This sounds very similar to Baumeister's idea. See the Earning Manhood section in his essay. Excerpt below.

So perhaps Baumeister's essay wouldn't be a revelation to some feminists. But is Baumeister wrong? Perhaps I am missing the difference. The main difference seems to be the feminist take is more normative.

--------

http://denisdutton.com/baumeister.htm

" The phrase “Be a man” is not as common as it once was, but there is still some sense that manhood must be earned. Every adult female is a woman and is entitled to respect as such, but many cultures withhold respect from the males until and unless the lads prove themselves. This is of course tremendously useful for the culture, because it can set the terms by which males earn respect as men, and in that way it can motivate the men to do things that the culture finds productive.

Some sociological writings about the male role have emphasized that to be a man, you have to produce more than you consume. That is, men are expected, first, to provide for themselves: If somebody else provides for you, you’re less than a man. Second, the man should create some additional wealth or surplus value so that it can provide for others in addition to himself. These can be his wife and children, or others who depend on him, or his subordinates, or even perhaps just paying taxes that the government can use. Regardless, you’re not a man unless you produce at that level.

Again, I’m not saying men have it worse than women. There are plenty of problems and disadvantages that cultures put on women. My point is just that cultures find men useful in these very specific ways. Requiring the man to earn respect by producing wealth and value that can support himself and others is one of these. Women do not face this particular challenge or requirement."

Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by A_COMPUTER on Sunday February 15, 2015 @01:29PM (#9053472)
If you'll note, I didn't trash on his work, I think it has a lot of value. My problem was his characterization of feminism as not having talked about these things and therefore implying they are a bunch of boobs. [edit] What is the cause of this system? What ideology is sustaining it? Is it on the whole good or bad? Normative description is not enough for many feminists, who have identified it as a problem and want to change it. It may be enough for him for his work, so that's a pretty significant difference.
Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by facepalm on Sunday February 15, 2015 @04:50PM (#9054285)
The cause is biology, he explains it in the speech/book. It's actually pretty simple to understand - men are expendable because sperm is cheap. Wombs are a limited resource, sperm isn't. (In a nutshell).

I think feminism having a theory doesn't amount to much in itself. Religion also has a theory that "explains" the world. But it isn't science. Neither is feminism (in most cases).

I'm also amused because of course it is in the women's power to change men's behavior - simply change who they mate with. If they prefer mating with the most powerful men, men will compete to be the most powerful men. It's not the patriarchy creating that, it's women's choices. (Although it's possible that women's choices make biological sense, but I've never seen a feminist who cared much for evolution theory).

Another interesting thought which I think is from Nassim Taleb: religions did a lot for peace by mandating monogamy and making sure more men got access to a womb that way.

Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by graeme on Sunday February 15, 2015 @01:56PM (#9053576)
Got it. My bad. I improperly combined your comment with the criticisms of Baumeister I read that disagreed with him but didn't say why. Sorry about that.

By the way, I meant normative means they want to change it, whereas positivist would be merely describing a system. Baumeister seems more positivist.

I definitely agree that Baumeister didn't engage with feminist talk on this issue. I think he was responding to public discourses on issues like wage gaps, which don't necessarily correspond to more nuanced feminist narratives.

Re:How Roy Baumeister challenged the idea of self-esteem (2014) by A_COMPUTER on Sunday February 15, 2015 @02:01PM (#9053598)
I wasn't clear enough separating his useful work from his feelings on feminism, and my initial post was vitriolic toward him. I can do better next time.