News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook challenges Obama with impassioned stan... by d23 on Saturday February 14, 2015 @01:37PM (#9050364)
> For the average person, they've grown up in a world where they've learned through school, the media, their parents, and 95% of other sources of knowledge about this world that the State (in an abstract form, not with an R, D, or other political party affiliation tied to it because of those currently in power) is a protector, friend, keeper of order, etc. To attack or criticize the State (in abstract terms) and say that it could potentially abuse it's power, is like saying that your parents or some other loved one could potentially betray you.

This is cringeworthy. I knew HN had a Ron Paul bent, but has it been completely overtaken by 15 year olds?

Go ask ANYONE, your cashier, your hairdresser, or the random joe working on your car -- the standard line of thinking isn't that the government is some nice friend and protector. The standard line of thinking is that government is dysfunctional and politicians are corrupt. You people pick up a copy of 1984 and suddenly you're all mini-orwells running around spewing your "insights" to whoever will stand around long enough to pretend they care.

> If someone tells you your mother or father could potentially steal from you because their name is tied to your bank account, how does that make you feel? Do you feel like this person is right, or you do get defensive and say that could never possibly happen? Most defend their parents and their parents' trustworthiness. The same goes for their view of the State.

Oh, wise sage, please enlighten us with more of your wisdom. Tell us the story of the bunny going to the store to buy milk this time!

Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook challenges Obama with impassioned stan... by woodman on Saturday February 14, 2015 @03:29PM (#9050697)
> The standard line of thinking is that government is dysfunctional and politicians are corrupt.

That may be the standard response you get, but doesn't mean that is what they think. I'm sure that if you asked them how their day was going, you'd get a "fine" - which doesn't mean anything either. It makes more sense to look at actions than words: people still call the police if they get shorted a chicken nugget. Mothers still call the police to scare their rebellious teenagers straight. People still vote. So it is more likely that people are unhappy with the present government, but if they could just get their guy in office - then everything would be great. Give us a kindly king :)

Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook challenges Obama with impassioned stan... by philwelch on Saturday February 14, 2015 @04:21PM (#9050826)
Calling upon government services and voting isn't a show of faith in the government, it's just a matter of practicality. Do I fundamentally have faith in the police to protect people's safety instead of jeopardizing it? No, because they murder people all the time and get away with it. But I'm still going to file a police report when my laptop gets stolen because that's the only way I can make an insurance claim for it.

As for voting, I'm to the point where I just vote on ballot measures and leave the actual races for elected positions blank, unless there's a socialist running in which case I vote against them.

Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook challenges Obama with impassioned stan... by woodman on Saturday February 14, 2015 @04:48PM (#9050904)
> Calling upon government services and voting isn't a show of faith in the government, it's just a matter of practicality.

Intelligent people can disagree on the ideal way to transition from our present system to a more preferable solution - but your statement isn't absolutely true. Voting does demonstrate a faith in the government. That faith may only be that the present system allows for a transition through the mechanism of majority rule, but it is faith none the less. As far as police interactions, I chose my examples carefully - they demonstrate a belief in the state beyond practical needs such as insurance claims.

Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook challenges Obama with impassioned stan... by daeken on Saturday February 14, 2015 @03:09PM (#9050642)
While I do tend to agree with you, this is a content-free comment; it has no purpose but to mock the parent commenter. When commenting, please keep things civil and constructive.
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook challenges Obama with impassioned stan... by d23 on Saturday February 14, 2015 @09:10PM (#9051552)
I do try to usually, but really, what more of substance could I have said? I'm starting to question whether being civil really is the proper response when you hear something that violates your views so strongly. Anyway, I appreciate your response.
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook challenges Obama with impassioned stan... by youngthugger on Saturday February 14, 2015 @02:20PM (#9050489)
Thank you I'm tired of this constant distorted view its really sad considering hackernews is built around intelligent conversations.
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook challenges Obama with impassioned stan... by bsbechtel on Saturday February 14, 2015 @02:28PM (#9050512)
I think I proved my point here.