News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sergey Aleynikov Sues FBI Agents Who Arrested Him by trhway on Friday February 13, 2015 @04:21PM (#9047274)
>But help me understand what the FBI did wrong, or Goldman for that matter.

What law Goldman reported violation of? What law FBI investigated violation of? While one can report some alleged violation of some law, the FBI is aware of laws, especially the laws the FBI is assigned to enforce. Bringing charges under obviously un-applicable here NSPA and EEA instead of whatever (if any) law may have been applicable here is a gross negligence, to say the least, on behalf of FBI. As a result, they wasted a lot of valuable (taxpayer) resources and ultimately let the criminal (if there was real crime committed) go free.

>The legal questions that were resolved in Aleynikov's favor were subtle ones.

are you kidding? How a subtle legal question(s) can be summarized in one paragraph on an Internet forum?

Re:Sergey Aleynikov Sues FBI Agents Who Arrested Him by abalone on Friday February 13, 2015 @04:49PM (#9047438)
I would not say the EEA is "obviously un-applicable". As rayiner noted, it is a subtle matter of phrasing in the law.

When Congress updated the letter of the law they merely rephrased "included in a product that is produced for or placed in", which the court found to be not applicable to code not directly sold on the market, to "a product or service used in or intended for use in".[1]

I'm not sure how well that one paragraph in an Internet forum summarizes it, but that's literally the only change that Congress made to declare his actions illegal (should they happen again). And it was at the behest of the judge who overturned the conviction, who specifically noted a problem with the phrasing of the law while noting that he fully expected Congress meant to include these actions in the criminal code.

[1] http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/z?r112:H18DE2-0051

Re:Sergey Aleynikov Sues FBI Agents Who Arrested Him by rhino369 on Friday February 13, 2015 @04:59PM (#9047483)
The government got burned by a narrow interpretation of the law. Congress edited one of the laws to re-widen it after the ruling.

What he did is illegal now and everyone thought was illegal then.

He is also being charged under state law for it. It was also civil trade secret misappropriation and Goldman can sue him.

Like Rayiner said, he got off on a technicality.