Prof Robinson has to 'accept' the university's offer because the alternative is starvation and homelessness.
The university believes - wrongly, as it happens - that people like Prof Robinson are easy to replace. So it sees no need to treat him any better.
If he tries to argue for a fair rate, he's arguing as someone from an inferior position of power and status with 'rational actors' who don't understand the consequences of their actions.
In this case the consequences are poor teaching, and - in the medium term - the replacement of an overly greedy university system with something that offers better value for students.
I'm sure the admins are patting themselves on the back for putting Prof Robinson in his place.
They won't be so happy when everyone - including the student body - has moved elsewhere.
>Are bright young people being indoctrinated with a sense of personal sacrifice for the cause of 'higher learning', not unlike a cult?
No, bright people are being indoctrinated in business and econ classes with the idea that you should make a fast buck however you can. Social transactions can only be valued financially. Nothing else matters.
Those are the real cult victims. As is Prof Robinson, who is one of many talented individual dealing with the consequences of that particular brand of kookiness.
This is not rhetoric. These toxic attitudes exist because they've been heavily promoted. They didn't just happen.
Are you using "wrongly" in the sense of "what they're doing is wrong" or "their belief is incorrect"? Because the latter is absolutely not true. There is a near endless supply of freshly-minted PhDs willing the take the author's place.
However in your argument, with plenty of PhDs available the chances of finding another Prof Robinson should not be impossible. We can always find traits of teachers we like and dismiss others for similarly arbitrary reasons, the issue being how do you make this work for hiring decisions. One person's dream candidate may not even rate for another
The interesting issues at hand are the cultural factors of academia that cause so many highly qualified people to work for such astoundingly little money. Are bright young people being indoctrinated with a sense of personal sacrifice for the cause of 'higher learning', not unlike a cult? Are those self-issued 'high qualifications' not actually as valuable as they are pretended to be? Those are the interesting questions rather than just going "hurr durr supply and demand".
Not like the supply-and-demand argument excuses anything, either. The entire history of labor protections is that previous practices that the market would bear were deemed socially unjust and no longer permitted, even if you could still find people desperate enough to agree to them. Saying "you took the job; don't complain" simply isn't valid.