Re:Does Work Really Work?
by krapp on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @08:18PM
(#9036798)
The term is not controversial, but taking it seriously is, unless you're an anarchist and already assume that all societal constructs are attempts at coercion or slavery to begin with.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I am. I do assume that.
What else would they be?
How do you have a societal construct that isn't coerced?
Voluntary participation of 100% of participants ....
I would argue that such a definition dilutes terms like 'slavery' or 'coercion' to the point that they become nearly meaningless.
Is this discussion we're having right now really worth considering a form of slavery? Am I attempting to control you, or are you attempting to control me? In this context, can it even be argued that language itself is an act of violence, or that there is even anything wrong with slavery, if it defines human interaction at so many fundamental levels?
After all anarchy itself is a societal construct, with commonly accepted norms, accepted practices, attitudes, cults of personality. What would happen in a perfect anarchist society when someone inevitably questioned anarchy?