Weight loss is rarely the primary goal of FMT and its efficacy in that realm remains unproven. Nowhere did the article imply that any of the things that made you "cringe" are necessary. And oral administration isn't objectively better than the alternatives, nor is it always an option since many people understandably find the idea of swallowing a "poop pill" rather repulsive.
He didn't say it was the primary goal. In fact, the way I read it it was a side effect.
Well, doesn't this case demonstrate that FMT can be used to have an effect on weight, albeit in the negative sense? So something is going on here, and while the science is unproven, it sure seems like this incident demonstrates that it has promise.
Luckily there has been a rapid uptake in FMT and we'll have good correlational data sooner rather than later.
> This has been found to work for weight loss; you give a normal-weight donor's microbiome to an overweight person, and they lose weight a significant fraction of the time.
Do you have cite for this? I think there is some circumstantial evidence on this, but it's far from settled.
Why? These transplants are so new and cutting edge that we don't know if taking from an obese person will be a bad or good thing, anecdotes like this might help us form an educated opinion, but it is too early to say for sure.
You certainly cannot say for sure if that was a mistake because few know that really...
Taking fecal matter from someone who is overweight stacking the probabilities away from your favour.
As always, science doesn't happen via "Eureka!" but by "Well that's strange...".
Perhaps the patient opted for the colonoscopy the avoid the "unpleasantness" of swallowing a capsule of fecal matter. It may not taste like shit, but you know it is.
Why did that make you cringe in particular?
So, when I read:
> the woman received a fecal transplant from her overweight but healthy daughter, via colonoscopy
I cringed. There are three things wrong with that. First: you don't need to use a relative, because fecal transplants don't have risk of rejection. Second, you wouldn't use a donor who's overweight. And third, it's normally done with a swallowed capsule, not with a colonoscopy, which adds risk and unpleasantness for no reason.
(Edit: The primary source says "With the occurrence of weight gain after FMT in this case, it is now our policy to use nonobese donors for FMT. The untoward consequences of using nonideal FMT donors are important, because patients may prefer to use a family member rather than an unrelated or unknown stool donor due to the perception that these sources are safer.")