People wanted social services, the ability to watch cat videos yesterday, and to not have to pay anything for it.
Other people wanted money for those services. So a trade happened.
This is like asking "In your manstion, did you really want to pay $10,000,000 for it?" Sure it would have been nice to have a free mansion.
Now that you mention it, I think I would like a silver platter. Just put it on the steel one. Actually, make it two, so I can still use one while the other is being polished. And have a silver polisher bring the next tray. And make sure she has read Dune, and has a D.V.M. with a specialty in herpetology.
What's that? My choices are actually between a gaping stab wound and a turd sandwich? I'll take the sandwich, I guess....
I'm reminded of the news story a few years ago where Target effectively broke news of a teen pregnancy to the girl's dad.[0] I doubt the teen realized that by shopping at Target she was agreeing to divulge information about her teen pregnancy, but that was the deal she brokered when she bought lotion and prenatal vitamins using a credit card instead of cash.
[0] http://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2012/02/16/how-targe...
You have to consider it in terms of tradeoffs instead of absolute "wants," but yes. We apparently want banner ads more than subscription services. DRM is apparently a cost we're willing to pay in order to enjoy entertainment, and privacy seems to be less valuable than convenience and connectedness.
Not saying I, or anyone in particular, values things that way, but I do think we've ended up with what "we" want.
[0] - http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/30/meditations-on-moloch/
Further even if we had consumer-pays-for-content sites as low friction as advertiser-pays-for-content sites they still would likely converge towards having advertisements (ultimately maybe less, maybe not) to maximize earnings.
I think there are solutions to these problems but I think they require us to first rethink the assessment and reward of creativity, talent and effort in scarcity-free systems.
This seems a little simplistic because you take manipulation, hacking, externalities and profit motive out of the equation. In the real world, did people want despots and obesity epidemics?
On the Internet, did people want banner ads, DRM, and a loss of privacy?