News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Occupy GPL the movement to rid the world of non-permissiv... by tptacek on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @02:48PM (#9029422)
If you release your code under the GPL (or even the AGPL) and discover after a few months that your community would work better if the code was MIT licensed, you can always release under a new license.

If, on the other hand, you release under the MIT license and discover after a few months that your "community" is a bunch of product companies using your code without contributing anything back, you cannot easily GPL your code. Everything you released under the maximally permissive license will stay released that way.

Think also of the dynamics of forks. If you look at GPL->MIT and MIT->GPL as two instances of a fork, it's easy to see why GPL->MIT leaves you with the winning fork: people will probably gravitate towards the more permissive fork. On the other hand, if you fork and GPL, your competitors will have a lot of incentive to make sure that the MIT fork wins.

People have a habit of looking at the GPL solely through the lens of politics and principles. But the GPL is also a very valuable business tool. It allows companies to open-source things that they wouldn't otherwise be willing to open.

Re:Occupy GPL the movement to rid the world of non-permissiv... by quadrangle on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @04:19PM (#9029972)
To be perfectly fair (although I totally agree with you!), if a project is copylefted and receives community contributions under that license without a Contributor License Agreement (which is arguably a bad and susect thing to require), this then makes the fork to more permissive much harder as it requires everyone's buy-in, whereas the fork the other way is always feasible, but still has the issues you bring up.

Overall, it would be a great thing if all code were AGPL and everyone had to simply work out reasonable livelihoods and business arrangements within that neutral commons framework. The issue is that a world of mixed proprietary and open code is an uneven one with tragedies of the commons. Copyleft helps avoid those tragedies, which every player actually wants to avoid.