I re-read C99, and the reason this is allowed is not because of §6.5.2.2 p10, but rather §6.5.16 p4 as far as I can tell. Though it's weird to me that the expression (x = 2) can ever be evaluated as anything but 2.
Also, it's not illegal C, it's undefined C and compilers are only allowed to do whatever they want within the undefined area (which is larger than I expected.)
Undefined C is illegal C, because the compiler is not even required to do the same thing from run to run.
Undefined is not the same as implementation defined.
Re:A very old gcc "bug"
by JoeAltmaier on Monday October 26, 2009 @10:13AM
(#903212)
Normally C compilers push arguments right-to-left, so probably evaluate them that way too.
Still can't explain x=2 coming out 3 tho...
It should be noted that this is illegal C, and compilers are allowed to do absolutely anything they want when they see it. Even things that are totally not logical.