News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A very old gcc "bug" by ars on Sunday October 25, 2009 @08:44PM (#902428)
Why not? It's doing the x=2 first (before anything else in there), then the ++ of the last expression (and returning 2 for it), then giving you the result of the middle one (which is now three since it ran after the last one). The 7 is because it ran that one before doing anything to the other values.

It should be noted that this is illegal C, and compilers are allowed to do absolutely anything they want when they see it. Even things that are totally not logical.

Re:A very old gcc "bug" by yuvi on Sunday October 25, 2009 @09:06PM (#902452)
I re-read C99, and the reason this is allowed is not because of §6.5.2.2 p10, but rather §6.5.16 p4 as far as I can tell. Though it's weird to me that the expression (x = 2) can ever be evaluated as anything but 2.

Also, it's not illegal C, it's undefined C and compilers are only allowed to do whatever they want within the undefined area (which is larger than I expected.)

Re:A very old gcc "bug" by ars on Monday October 26, 2009 @12:00AM (#902611)
Undefined C is illegal C, because the compiler is not even required to do the same thing from run to run.

Undefined is not the same as implementation defined.

Re:A very old gcc "bug" by JoeAltmaier on Monday October 26, 2009 @10:13AM (#903212)
Normally C compilers push arguments right-to-left, so probably evaluate them that way too. Still can't explain x=2 coming out 3 tho...