Isn't it because the prices of the houses were highly inflated, due to very easy credit?
Do you think that the rest of the economy is a bubble like the 2008 housing bubble?
I don't think it matters why an asset deprecates. For a local example a mine/plant/army base closes and suddenly lots of houses are worth far less money.
Hypothetically, if a disease kills off 25% of the population housing prices nationally are going to fall like a rock. They might not have been overvalued, but there suddenly worth less money. Deflation is less gruesome, but you still end up with house value < outstanding loan.
The important thing from an economic perspective is simply value of asset vs debt.
The payment was unchanged, but there was a massive loss of flexibility as people could not sell under water houses.
Now expand that to the rest of the economy while lot's of leveraged companies and investments fail.