Source: I founded GrubHub and wrote the article referenced here.
I guess no amount of financial engineering can unscrew the little guy. :)
BTW, love your company and use it often, thank you!
I don't know how they'd enforce this, however. Seems like you'd have to have a big mouth, and they'd have to be willing to fire you for it.
It does vary state by state, though, so I suppose it's possible that some states have laws that prevent you from trading in derivatives during a lockup period.
I'm guessing even if it were a potential issue, enough time had passed from the IPO, and it's unlikely the same restrictions apply to an acquisition. Cuban likely held his shares free and clear at that point.
A $1.4 billion collar would have drawn a lot of attention from the SEC, doubly so given the publicity and scale of the Yahoo transaction.
I've been watching a couple companies closely to figure out when/if they're going to go and now I have a better sense of the process.
1) Options don't start trading until well after the stock has gone public, usually atleast 3 months so you can't use this method to hedge out of the IPO gate. This is an exchange issue, not a liquidity issue.
2) So, after selling calls you can take that money you made from the premium and buy puts with it at around the same price.
Put call parity assures you that you won't make enough selling calls to buy puts at around the same price. ie you'll need to put some of your own money into this. I think the author did a good job of indicating this but it should be made clear to people before tyring to do this.
To be clear, following this strategy it helps lock in a price lower than the current market price for your shares, so you know what you'll make if the stock goes down.
However it also means that if the stock takes off you won't get any of the upside. Keep that in mind as it can be very hard psychologically to watch everyone else around you make money while you've capped your upside.
And you're right, options generally take some time to begin trading - especially if the volume is low on the common stock anyhow.
Another method if you can is simply short the stock as soon as you like the price. Then replace the stock when your stock is freed up. Naturally this requires margin and problem that you could get margin called if the stock goes through the roof! Hedge with calls then that are way out of the money then too.
Also, there's the issue of shorting your own company!
Sell calls at the price you want to sell for the month that the lockup expires. If your shares get called away you got the price you wanted and some premium. However, you miss out on a huge gain if it goes far beyond your call level. Also, if the stock tanks in that time you keep your now less valuable shares but you got some premium.
So, after selling calls you can take that money you made from the premium and buy puts with it at around the same price. You've created a spread here and have locked in a selling price and gave yourself some downside insurance - all for very little cost to you over all since the covered call premium paid for most, if not all of your puts. Your only risk now is that the stock goes through the roof and you miss out on some upside - but that makes sense as you've eliminated risk for very little out of pocket cost. So maybe you do this on 1/2 or 2/3 of your position or whatever you're comfortable with.
Of course the difficulty is if you have a ton of stock and the option market for your company isn't very large and therefore illiquid.