News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What we actually know about software development, and why... by derefr on Sunday October 25, 2009 @03:52PM (#902046)
You're agreeing with the parent. There are metrics to measure solving well-known problems, but no metrics for researching problems to make them well-known.
Re:What we actually know about software development, and why... by gaius on Sunday October 25, 2009 @04:03PM (#902059)
But the first person or team who realized that you could put a computer in an aircraft weren't solving a known problem - however they were using engineering methods, which is why it's very rare for avionics to (literally!) crash.

Here's my theory: we do know how to build very high quality software in a repeatable way. However very few organizations are willing to pay what it costs to do that, and that is why most software is so bad. Admittedly a lot of people writing code these days are "cowboys" (they don't care and neither do their clients, they just want speed) but that doesn't mean that the body of knowledge doesn't exist.

Re:What we actually know about software development, and why... by pmichaud on Sunday October 25, 2009 @04:30PM (#902088)
I don't know why this comment was voted down, but I think he could be right -- given the correct resources (time mainly), and assuming the right talent level, I think we could consistently build rock-solid software. The constraint seems to be a (logical and necessary) trade off between total cost and total utility.

As we all know, something that works 95% of the time at 5% the price is very often better than a "perfect" solution. With critical systems like plane navigation, the tradeoff doesn't make sense, so you pay full price for near-perfection... your niche e-commerce site? 95% is sufficient.

Re:What we actually know about software development, and why... by Agent101 on Sunday October 25, 2009 @05:23PM (#902168)
Plane navigation is in someways easier to e-commerce sites as well. The environment that the plane is in, isn't actively malicious. You can collect accurate statistics on weather, where as the attacks and usage (with bots/scraping etc) consistently change.
Re:What we actually know about software development, and why... by Quarrelsome on Sunday October 25, 2009 @06:25PM (#902251)
Not at all man. The physical environment can be much more malicious than you seem to think.

I've done some software for buses, it's toy in comparison (with planes) but you get issues with noise, power supply, vibration, temperature, light (UV killing a touch screen) and probably lots more i've never encountered. The physical world can be every bit as unpredictable as the virtual one.

Re:What we actually know about software development, and why... by yters on Sunday October 25, 2009 @10:39PM (#902527)
The major difference is that environmental agents are generally deterministic or stochastic, i.e. obey the law of physics. On the other hand, realms with intelligent agents, such as humans, are inherently unpredictable due to their free will (which is unpredictable by definition).
Re:What we actually know about software development, and why... by Quarrelsome on Monday October 26, 2009 @11:59AM (#903454)
You also have the free will of humans messing with the system (in my case, fraud prevention), also consider animals interacting the machinary while someone is not watching. I remember hearing a story about a huntsman spider regularily tripping a sensor for a program that measured the weight of lorries.

The only consistent thing you can state is that all these "real world" issues are to do with hardware whereas yours are more softwarey. However the consideration of such issues is necessary across the board.

Re:What we actually know about software development, and why... by nopassrecover on Monday October 26, 2009 @02:55AM (#902743)
I don't know about you but if I was writing a program to fly a plane I'd want to make damn sure I took into account an intelligent malicious agent trying to crash my plane.
Re:What we actually know about software development, and why... by gaius on Monday October 26, 2009 @03:47AM (#902787)
E-commerce has been around for >15 years now, and there how many tens or hundreds of thousands of e-commerce sites? It's a very well known problem by now.