News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Silver: A free implementation of Swift for .NET, Java, An... by ttflee on Monday February 09, 2015 @04:54AM (#9020403)
The problem is not whether it is legal to use Swift in a 3rd party environment, but the lack of support in the 3rd party eco-system per se means the attempt would vanish, in time.

I believe most of us who actually use Objective-C choose it not because the language itself is designed to be simple and elegant, (and yes the language is simple and elegant,) but because the Cocoa and Cocoa-Touch are well supported by Apple. No offence to the effort outside of APPL, but it is not enough to support a full-fledged eco-system with all 3rd-party F/OSS written in Objective-C that is compatible with what Apple currently uses in order to build reusable components. GNUStep has existed for so many years, and Étoilé for years as well, but I did not see emergence of adoption in community comparable to that of other popular F/OSS frameworks, e.g. Mono and Qt. And I do not see how this issue could be circumvented, unless some big player shows up and adopt any of these projects, like what Google did to Android.

There are no comments on this comment yet.