I'm not claiming a GUI hampers learning Git but just to offer some experience of it not being necessary.
With that said, this is very cool - https://pcottle.github.io/learnGitBranching/
Or well, it was when it worked. This seems similar, in spirit, but not as good as learnGitBranch was... - https://onlywei.github.io/explain-git-with-d3/
In trying to be simple they often left me feeling powerless
Have you tried SourceTree? That's the one I tend to recommend these days. Alternatively, if you're prepared to splash out a bit, SmartGit is worth considering too.
- staging portions of many files scattered across a directory tree
- quickly glancing over diffs for a given commit
- understanding the commit graph and the relationship between local and remote branches
Each developer's experience may vary, but in general I feel like a good GUI tool can help a novice user develop and reinforce the mental model necessary to understand what git is doing. For example, what am I doing when I rebase my commit onto master vs merging it?This should be an interactive tutorial with visualization. It is currently broken for me (Chrome-Linux). There is screenshot on Github:
Personally I'm in love with Magit which is a thin Emacs wrapper around git.
Some of the concepts behind DVCS, such as the DAG, merging, resolving conflicts, even the staging area, are much easier to understand when you can actually visualise them. I've found that people who try to jump in at the deep end with the command line sometimes don't understand Git as well as they think they do.
These days I tend to use the command line a lot more, and I would strongly recommend people to do so once they've mastered the core concepts, but I still like to have a GUI to hand so I can see at a glance where things are at with my branches, staging area, etc.