News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Samsung Global Privacy Policy - SmartTV Supplement by learnstats2 on Sunday February 08, 2015 @09:45AM (#9017343)
It used to be the case that a service would politely ask you whether or not they could collect data about you, and would provide the same service in both cases.

This option (to minimise data collection/retention) ought to be enshrined in law.

If you pay (or not) for a service, you should be able to get the service without the expectation of your personal and private data being harvested.

Re:Samsung Global Privacy Policy - SmartTV Supplement by vidarh on Sunday February 08, 2015 @09:51AM (#9017356)
In this case the issue is that it is not possible for them to provide the service without potentially collecting private data:

The voice recognition is done on remote servers, and they have no means of preventing you from saying something private when it is recording.

Re:Samsung Global Privacy Policy - SmartTV Supplement by DanBC on Sunday February 08, 2015 @09:54AM (#9017366)
The TV could store a "wake up" word locally. The TV doesn't send any audio anywhere until you speak the wakeup word, at which point in beeps and a light flashes and then all audio is sent away to the cloud for processing.
Re:Samsung Global Privacy Policy - SmartTV Supplement by chkuendig on Sunday February 08, 2015 @10:24AM (#9017447)
This is exactly how Amazon Echo does it:

Amazon Echo uses on-device keyword spotting to detect the wake word. When Amazon Echo detects the wake word, Amazon Echo streams audio to the Cloud, including a fraction of a second of audio before the wake word.

http://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html?nodeId=2...

Re:Samsung Global Privacy Policy - SmartTV Supplement by mkal_tsr on Sunday February 08, 2015 @01:49PM (#9018072)
> including a fraction of a second of audio before the wake word.

Interesting that they are able to transmit audio-data that occurred prior to the wake word being said (in essence to transmit the wake word). Looks like Amazon is keen to redefine "collected" just like other groups are...

Re:Samsung Global Privacy Policy - SmartTV Supplement by ars on Sunday February 08, 2015 @02:30PM (#9018212)
Why is that interesting? It's quite simple since the device is always listening locally, and just storing a second of audio in a buffer.

It's not "collected" since it only has 1 second of audio until it wakes up.

Re:Samsung Global Privacy Policy - SmartTV Supplement by mkal_tsr on Monday February 09, 2015 @12:12AM (#9019782)
Because every time Amazon echo comes up, people always rush it "don't worry guys, it's not actually recording anything until it has to send to the cloud" and by Amazon's own admission, that's patently false.
Re:Samsung Global Privacy Policy - SmartTV Supplement by ars on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @12:24AM (#9025529)
Um, no, that's patently true.

Unless you are talking about the half second before the trigger word? But even then - it only sends when triggered.

Re:Samsung Global Privacy Policy - SmartTV Supplement by mkal_tsr on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @06:14AM (#9026493)
I am indeed talking about the 1/2 second before. Even if it's 0.00001 seconds before the trigger word (I feel dirty saying that phrase), it's the technicality that I'm discussing. Once we allow those technicalities to slide, the truth is easier to bend and/or ignore. Reinforcing that PR/marketing is not an acceptable excuse to lie (even if it's a minor technical lie) is one of the few ways to prevent this sort of subtle-switcheroo.
Re:Samsung Global Privacy Policy - SmartTV Supplement by ars on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @04:55PM (#9030198)
> I am indeed talking about the 1/2 second before.

Then you are alone in this. Even amongst technological people, never mind the general public. This amount of time is perfectly reasonable.

> Once we allow those technicalities to slide, the truth is easier to bend and/or ignore.

No it doesn't. Slippery slope might be a valid argument in some places, but not here. You are overreacting.

> to prevent this sort of subtle-switcheroo.

There is no subtle switcheroo.

It's very very simple: It only sends audio when commanded to. That is the essence of the difference, and it's all that matters.

And don't tell me "next they'll send 1 hour of audio when triggered" because they won't. You are being ridiculous if you think that's where it's headed.

Taking outrageous positions like this just makes people ignore you.

> the trigger word (I feel dirty saying that phrase)

? Why? Does it have some special meaning I am not aware of?

Re:Samsung Global Privacy Policy - SmartTV Supplement by vidarh on Sunday February 08, 2015 @12:27PM (#9017795)
True, but that still does not prevent the possibility of it capturing private conversations ongoing in the room.
Re:Samsung Global Privacy Policy - SmartTV Supplement by learnstats2 on Sunday February 08, 2015 @09:56AM (#9017369)
> The voice recognition is done on remote servers

While possible, this is not theoretically necessary, and I find this highly doubtful in practice.

What about the delay on each voice command as it pings the server? If it was generally the case that voice commands were sent remotely, I suggest usability would be 0.

Re:Samsung Global Privacy Policy - SmartTV Supplement by maccard on Sunday February 08, 2015 @10:14AM (#9017422)
Siri, and Cortana (iOS and WP8 voice recognition engines) both send the clip to a remote server to perform recognition.

There are many services that provide real time processing of large amounts of data on server cluster/farms, and more are coming. It is very much possible to perform large computations in almost real time in these situations, and you'd be surprised at how little latency people notice, particularly when there's no indication of what the actual number is.

Re:Samsung Global Privacy Policy - SmartTV Supplement by learnstats2 on Sunday February 08, 2015 @10:37AM (#9017492)
I wasn't aware that people generally found Siri usable.
Re:Samsung Global Privacy Policy - SmartTV Supplement by thanksgiving on Sunday February 08, 2015 @10:51AM (#9017524)
It is genuinely comic when I see what kind of questions my non-technical friends ask Siri. I can't imagine the thought process of how Siri could put together the information from the ramblings of a person much less answer the query...
Re:Samsung Global Privacy Policy - SmartTV Supplement by maccard on Sunday February 08, 2015 @01:17PM (#9017966)
That doesn't add anything to this discussion. Siri is more than usable for a lot of things - I can set alarms, timers, and make calls without reaching for my phone. I'm not saying that it's revolutionary, but it definitely works.
Re:Samsung Global Privacy Policy - SmartTV Supplement by learnstats2 on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @04:53PM (#9030177)
From my point of view it did add significantly to the discussion.

I'm surprised to learn that people do use Siri in genuine situations, so thanks for your reply in that regard; although I still feel gratified that another commenter has the same experience that I do.

Re:Samsung Global Privacy Policy - SmartTV Supplement by vidarh on Sunday February 08, 2015 @12:29PM (#9017802)
It is not theoretically necessary if the local unit has sufficient capacity, which it doesn't in most current implementations. Hence why most implementations of voice recognition in consumer hardware does send the clips off to remote servers for processing.

Judge the delay for yourself.

Re:Samsung Global Privacy Policy - SmartTV Supplement by polarix on Sunday February 08, 2015 @10:23AM (#9017445)
It might be practically necessary, though, if they need to have a huge corpus of data in memory in order to perform their voice recognition.
Re:Samsung Global Privacy Policy - SmartTV Supplement by dolant on Monday February 09, 2015 @10:45PM (#9025281)
I'd believe it, my friend had one and the delay on all commands in all forms was very 'laggy'.
Re:Samsung Global Privacy Policy - SmartTV Supplement by darkmighty on Sunday February 08, 2015 @10:21AM (#9017440)
The delay is approximately the same or less of what fast local evaluation would be (ping within a country should be <50ms).
Re:Samsung Global Privacy Policy - SmartTV Supplement by falcolas on Sunday February 08, 2015 @10:38AM (#9017497)
If you're on wired internet, if you aren't saturating your local network, if your provider isn't having any issues, if their servers are up, if there is no DNS delay or caching issues, if...

Relying on the internet for "real time" computation is a recipe for inconsistent behavior.

Re:Samsung Global Privacy Policy - SmartTV Supplement by hueving on Sunday February 08, 2015 @01:13PM (#9017953)
The fact that people are using these features of android and apple phones shows that it's 'good enough'. I frequently use it to issue navigation commands on my phone and it fails maybe 1 in 25 times. Well worth not typing in destinations when I want to go somewhere quickly.
Re:Samsung Global Privacy Policy - SmartTV Supplement by vidarh on Sunday February 08, 2015 @12:26PM (#9017789)
The alternative, for the moment, is to not have the functionality at all.