to whit:
Wed Jan 11 00:33:40 EST 2006, CLAY SHENTRUP
CLAY at BROKENLADDER.COM wrote:
>
> On 1/10/06, Daniel Guido <dguido at
> gmail.com> wrote:
>>
>> Correct me if I'm wrong, but there is no
>> working implementation of OTR for e-mail
>> yet is there?
>
> There can't be really. The sender and
> receiver have to agree upon a shared secret
> at the time of transmition, which requires
> at least 3 passes.So, again, what's wrong with telling people to ignore PGP/GnuPG altogether?
-- Assange to Google's Schmidt: 'I don't use email'
http://www.computerworld.com/article/2496908/encryption/assa...
And as Assange said, if you are e.g. a journalist in the government watchlist, it could be worse (more dangerous) than not using gpg/pgp.
Text messages using OTR seems like a better way. For widespread crypto usage, telling people to ignore pgp/gpg and use texts with OTR seems more reasonable than keeping projects like GnuPG alive.
If I were running a company like Facebook who's interested in spying on people, I might even fund projects like GnuPG so that unrealistic geeks keep thinking this is a viable solution.
As for facebook, as long as they keep the XMPP access open and supported[1], at least they do support OTR. Unlike eg: google.
I don't really understand this "gpg is impossibly hard"-stance. Yes, security is hard. Why recommend OTR? Don't get me wrong, I love OTR -- but verifying OTR keys, and transporting identities across devices (eg: when getting a new phone) is pretty difficult too. Are you saying wrong use of OTR is better than wrong use of gpg, because most people that use OTR use it in a way that allow for MITM anyway?
But most importantly, the point you seem to ignore, it's not secure if you don't verify keys. I'd say most people don't verify keys with OTR -- hence they're not using it in a manner that's actually secure. I do agree that it's a lot better than people using Snapchat.
Almost nobody can use PGP/GnuPG properly and OTR is reasonably easy to use for most people. Isn't this alone a good reason to just tell people to ignore PGP/GnuPG altogether?