Re:Once-starving GnuPG crypto project gets a windfall. Now c...
by tptacek on Friday February 06, 2015 @05:28PM
(#9011982)
Yes, that EFF scorecard is terrible.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Once-starving GnuPG crypto project gets a windfall. Now c...
by stinkytaco on Friday February 06, 2015 @05:39PM
(#9012039)
Care to elaborate on that? I'm in the habit of more or less trusting the EFF, but I don't use cryptocat (no need for it) and I have heard that it is insecure. My understanding (possibly flawed), is that it was mostly tied to the JS Crypto implementation.
What about the rest of the scorecard?
Re:Once-starving GnuPG crypto project gets a windfall. Now c...
by tptacek on Friday February 06, 2015 @05:42PM
(#9012066)
You can look around for what other crypto and security people thought of the EFF scorecard. It was not well-regarded.
They factored the JS into a Chrome application awhile back, and while Chrome-extension JS crypto isn't particular safe either (there are realistic side-channel attacks on it), it's not the cluster•••• that content-controlled JS crypto is.
There are much, much bigger problems with Cryptocat than Javascript. I would also recommend avoiding the mobile apps, which are native.
Re:Once-starving GnuPG crypto project gets a windfall. Now c...
by woah on Saturday February 07, 2015 @03:17AM
(#9013447)
Pray tell
Re:Once-starving GnuPG crypto project gets a windfall. Now c...
by Strom on Saturday February 07, 2015 @05:23AM
(#9013606)
This is a good post pointing out some of the problems with CryptoCat http://tobtu.com/decryptocat.php
Re:Once-starving GnuPG crypto project gets a windfall. Now c...
by DanBC on Saturday February 07, 2015 @05:27AM
(#9013615)
That scorecard carefully says that it's not an endorsement of any product yet here in this thread we have someone using it as an endorsement of a product.
The scorecard lists "good features" and gives you a tick if you claim to offer that feature. The score card does not currently test any of those and certainly hasn't tested the auditing or done their own audit.