News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Can worker cooperatives alleviate income inequality? by mc32 on Friday February 06, 2015 @04:31PM (#9011677)
I'm not sure a cooperative is going to alleviate income inequality. When you form the cooperative, I imagine the first member and subsequent members would filter for ability, qualifications, productivity, etc. So the same "average" and bellow average worker would be left out. How are the passed over want-to-be workers going get in on the cooperative and thus enjoy an income and presumably above average income?

Are the cooperatives going to take on slackers or averagely skilled people wanting to join? How would that cooperative compete against more 'competitive' cooperatives?

Re:Can worker cooperatives alleviate income inequality? by sanderjd on Friday February 06, 2015 @04:47PM (#9011774)
Your comment seems to presuppose that income inequality is largely the result of differences in skill and/or work levels, which is a common viewpoint that is not necessarily correct. The alternate viewpoint is that there are a lot of hard-working people with highly valuable skills who are underpaid due to the way corporations are usually structured. In a typical corporate structure, the people closest to the money are the best paid, which doesn't necessarily imply that they are the hardest working or mostly highly skilled.
Re:Can worker cooperatives alleviate income inequality? by mc32 on Friday February 06, 2015 @04:57PM (#9011827)
You're right. But my question is about income from those at the margins who are laid off fired etc. Due to stack ranking, etc. How is that addressed? It's important to get those people in the economy as much as its important to attenuate cxo salaries...
Re:Can worker cooperatives alleviate income inequality? by TaylorAlexander on Friday February 06, 2015 @08:00PM (#9012585)
I imagine a compartmentalized market of coops where highly successful coops have only a few employees with a large salary, and then they buy goods and services from other coops that may make less money and therefore cost less. So a robotics design coop may make $500k per employee but only have 5 employees. When they ship products they could ship via a shipping coop that only pays $60k per worker.

This allows some room for exploitation but it would probably better adjust for real market value of workers than what we have now.

Re:Can worker cooperatives alleviate income inequality? by mc32 on Friday February 06, 2015 @08:29PM (#9012684)
Doesn't this result is similar income disparity that this idea is trying to avoid? So instead of expressing itself between intra corp hierarchy it's expressed extra-corp hierarchy... So basically its exported but still exists...
Re:Can worker cooperatives alleviate income inequality? by spiralpolitik on Friday February 06, 2015 @08:03PM (#9012598)
The current model is unsustainable, more so when you factor in predictions that 50% of jobs could be automated within the next decades. [1]

I think a mix of cooperatives and a guaranteed base income, healthcare, and housing would allow those that wish to work to continue to do so while not forcing anybody to work who doesn't wish to offers a much better alternative to keeping inequality in check than the current system.

[1] http://www.technologyreview.com/view/519241/report-suggests-...

Re:Can worker cooperatives alleviate income inequality? by bryondowd on Friday February 06, 2015 @04:41PM (#9011744)
I assume the income inequality here is owner vs worker, rather than above average worker vs below average worker. I expect the gap between workers in most fields is much smaller than the gap between the owner's profits and the salaries of each worker.

The idea is that, in a traditional company, the owner (or stockholders) puts up all the investment and risk and in return, get the lion's share of the payoff. In the coop, there is no 'owner' and any profits that aren't reinvested in the company are divvied up by the workers. The trade-off is the difficulty in finding investment capital to get started, which is why many coops are simple businesses like cleaning services that can be started by workers pooling their resources.

Also, in regard to below average workers, I suppose that in many fields a coop could use productivity/skill/experience/etc to scale how big a slice of the pie each worker gets. This would allow any reasonable worker to be hired, while encouraging competitive productivity. It would all depend on the coop's rules.