Re:Katy Perry’s lawyers demand takedown of 3D printable Left...
by anigbrowl on Thursday February 05, 2015 @06:00PM
(#9006732)
NYU law professor Christopher Sprigman tweeted that he believes Left Shark is not copyrightable because it qualifies as a “useful article,”
Useful for what? It's silly for Katy Perry's lawyers to waste everyone's time on this, but that is presumably why they are paid a fat retainer, and the shark thingy looks eminently copyrightable to me, notwithstanding my complete lack of interest in Katy Perry, her music, or her stage show.
Re:Katy Perry’s lawyers demand takedown of 3D printable Left...
by davidgerard on Thursday February 05, 2015 @06:13PM
(#9006804)
Applying sense to copyright law will only lead to heartbreak. I would suggest the law professor knows more, and in any case the key point is that this looks like the sort of case where the most money wins.
Re:Katy Perry’s lawyers demand takedown of 3D printable Left...
by anigbrowl on Thursday February 05, 2015 @06:25PM
(#9006859)
I know copyright law pretty well, and a 'useful article' is just what it sounds like - something with a utilitarian function. http://www.copyright.gov/fls/fl103.html
I think that querying the utilitarian aspect of a toy shark is an entirely reasonable question, unless his original comment (which has since disappeared) was meant to be humorous.
Re:Katy Perry’s lawyers demand takedown of 3D printable Left...
by bruna597 on Friday February 06, 2015 @08:06AM
(#9008778)
The #LeftShark would be classified as a useful article if it was a costume. I dont think it was the case. I mean, the designer made it to be printed as a toy or a costume?
Useful for what? It's silly for Katy Perry's lawyers to waste everyone's time on this, but that is presumably why they are paid a fat retainer, and the shark thingy looks eminently copyrightable to me, notwithstanding my complete lack of interest in Katy Perry, her music, or her stage show.
I think that querying the utilitarian aspect of a toy shark is an entirely reasonable question, unless his original comment (which has since disappeared) was meant to be humorous.