Physicists and mathematicians often have the advantage that if they run an experiment / solve a problem by using the same inputs, they can expect the same output. Obviously this is not the case for economics, which at its core is driven by human interactions. Not only does it often have many, many variables, but they're also difficult to control.
In my estimation, it's actually impressive we have as good a grasp as we do on economics.
One version of the theory states that price information is just that - information - and you can't replace that with even excellent planning.
You could call China a hybrid of a planned/free economy, but as it's moved more to something akin to free markets, wealth has gone up, especially for the poorest there. This may be as close to an experiment as we can get in economics. Chinese Communism was never quite Soviet style Communism, but the results begin to look suspiciously like data.
>By exercising central control they should have been able to drastically reduce
people's entrepreneural activity as well as overall productivity. (note: i was born and grew up in USSR)
One of the most colorful examples of this comes not from economics, but a strange book on advertising called "The Hidden Persuaders". It also talks about erotic images airbrushed into the ice cubes of whiskey ads :) When I'd first heard of "Mad Men", I'd hoped it would be about that, but it wasn't.
I don't understand why even try to centrally plan the economy. It's stupid and doesn't make sense. Even if it was possible it would require resources to centrally run it. There would be no competitive edge because the economy is based on the people who participate in it. The information is already out there. It's publicly accessible. Centrally planning it would create an unnecessary middleman and break the perfect solution.
edit: clarification.
What's optimally? Seems that many people passionately disagree on this point and may help explain our difficulty in determining what should be done.
Additionally, economics is a young discipline that's more about trying to figure out unreproducible complex human behavior than something that can be replicated in a lab.
If you could fully explain an economic system down to the finest detail, you could more less accurately forecast all the human behavior within that system.
I take exception with the idea that economics is a human construct. Economics, in the broader sense of the term is about decision making and getting most out of limited resources.
Macro-economics is probably more like story telling or history rather than a hard science. It's a shame that it went the quantitative route over the years. No one tries to attribute an R^2 to a general's decision and their outcomes. I think modern macro-economics is suffering from scientism.
From Wikipedia: Scientism is belief in the universal applicability of the scientific method and approach, and the view that empirical science constitutes the most authoritative worldview or most valuable part of human learning to the exclusion of other viewpoints
You could easily argue that mathematics is something that is man-made.
If anything, events like negative interest rates simply illustrate how ridiculous the classical economic notion of the "rational actor" is in the real world.
This is a great example showing how little we understand economics, which is very ironic: economics is the study of something that is 100% man-made, yet we cannot explain many of its aspects. Heck I am more confident in physicists able to explain physics, and mathematicians able to explain mathematics, than in economists able to explain economics. This is why topics such as basic income guarantee [1], Bitcoin and cryptocurrencies, inflation vs deflation, capitalism vs socialism, etc, are all so debated. Nobody agrees on anything because quite frankly, we don't know how to make the economy work optimally. I would not be surprised if, 50 or 100 years from now, widely accepted views on economics will completely change.
[1] There was a great HN post from yesterday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9004287