And yes, the author's point is totally dead. How can one be able to pay 300$ every single month but unable to pay 600$ once every blue moon for a big repair? Predictability is oversold. The only fact remaining is people inability to live within their budget; if you can somehow put away 300$ every month when forced to pay for a new car's reimbursement, you should be able to put aside the half as much for future unknowns.
This is not theoretical since that's how I live and how I manage my car. I own a 2001 Corolla. I even had to change both the motor and transmission two years ago. The cost of which, including parts and labor, came down to less that one year's worth of payment on a new car.
You can buy used car. You can pay for repair. It's still cheaper than a new car, and you don't need magical privilege to do so.
(Simple real-world hindsight would tell anyone so. Just look around: poor people drive old cars. According to you and the author, they couldn't. Yet they do. So, which is wrong: reality or arguments on a page?)
Also, he said $170 for two hours of labor.
They see the title, then head right to the comment section to give their "superior" opinion.
I would say more than half of the people commenting here either did not read or did not absorb the message of the article.
Additionally, I'm mostly participating and reading the comments here because of the general topic of new vs used cars. The content, at least in this case, is irrelevant to me.
This whole discussion is coming across as if Americans have crap transport links, have no such things as taxis and really bad quality cars.
Because this discussion is just plain bonkers from a UK perspective.
General car advice is the minimum you should spend on a used car is at least $5000. And that's if you're really lucky. If you want a problem free used car for a usable amount of time (3-4 years) then you need to go up to at least $8000.
edit: Wanted to also point out that banks won't lend on cars that old or cheap or decrepit. Someone in that position who needs a car to get to work, has no option but to pay cash.
I haven't sold in that price range before, but I imagine at tax time there's some cars being bought for that price, certainly.
But no. I ended up selling it to a lady whose car had been totaled in an accident, and $1200 was what the insurance pay-out was. She had never driven a manual transmission before, so a Honda was a good choice for her to learn on. It was painful to listen to her grind gears as she drove away, though...
And that's ignoring all the other things that may affect the automotive industry over time, such as different regulations causing different materials to be used which can greatly affect how long the cars from that era may last. I own a car from 1973, I'm in no way confident that the same model car in 2015 will still be drivable in 40 years.
As to your last point, I have no reason to believe cars aren't lasting longer and longer. Engine life is determined more by use than age. (Do you have a million miles on your 40 year old car? Probably not)
New Toyota corolla: $16,000 2005 Toyota corolla: $4,000
I don't think there exists a scenario where you can end up outspending the MSRP if you buy a used previous model. Say for example your absolute lemon has chassis damage and needs to be scrapped (that's the absolute worst scenario). You still have $12,000 with which to buy another used car. Say you spend a whole week working on it to fix something catastrophic. I don't think anything would take that long but anyway. How many people actually make $12,000 in a week? Not many that need to save money on cars.