News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by windexh8er on Thursday February 05, 2015 @10:40AM (#9003744)
I feel most for those who have young children. If you consider the long term viability of SSN over the life-span of a person who is under the age of 5 today they'll likely have been exposed to a breach that will contain their dox a few times over by the time they reach a legal age - that is likely a conservative estimate given the frequency of these events. SSN is broken and we're going to see a lot of push back going forward as these people come of age.

TL;DR If you're a parent, monitor your child's SSN for activity. Especially considering this is a healthcare breach, nobody is immune.

Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by exelius on Thursday February 05, 2015 @11:48AM (#9004199)
SSN is not some secret number - they're actually public information and can be obtained through legal channels with minimal effort. SSN is simply used as a "primary key" to differentiate one John Smith from another; it's not a private passcode or anything (even though many places treat it as one). The main benefit of an SSN is that it's a unique identifier of a person, but it's not sufficient for establishing identity and should not be used for that purpose.
Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by windexh8er on Thursday February 05, 2015 @12:02PM (#9004323)
But it is private and it does unlock keys to lines of credit. It is not simply a "primary key" as stated, whether or not that was the original intent is not the argument here however. Recall the LifeLock CEO* plastered his SSN publicly and felt the repercussions. While I won't suggest you do that here - just knowing that if you did the assumption is bad things will happen in due time. Keeping SSNs private today is a risk organizations have to deal with and it does impact people, sometimes to an extensive length.

Also, for clarification, the breach involved all of the information required to establish identity - which was my main point in the protection and monitoring of the SSN, with special regard to children/minors.

* http://www.wired.com/2010/05/lifelock-identity-theft/

Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by exelius on Thursday February 05, 2015 @12:31PM (#9004527)
I heard about that, but when you publicly tell a bunch of hackers "come at me bro", you have to expect that kind of reaction.

But realistically, the cat is out of the bag with regards to SSNs. Legally you can obtain someone's SSN for very little money. If you go the illegal route, I'd be willing to bet that there is black-market identity data on over half of Americans. We really need to treat SSNs as about as secret as your e-mail address, because for all intents and purposes they are already. I wouldn't be surprised if online ad networks were using your SSN as a primary key in the background - the information is so easy to get and it would solve a lot of problems.

I guess I'm saying that sticking your head in the sand and pretending that SSNs are secure won't make them any more so. I'd doubt that a whole lot of SSNs were gathered in this hack that weren't already effectively disseminated widely in black market circles or marketing databases already.

Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by windexh8er on Thursday February 05, 2015 @12:47PM (#9004627)
Conversely getting 100k SSNs vs spending a significant amount of time and/or money on a handful is a different story. I'm not disputing that SSNs might be easy to obtain, but obtaining them at scale via breaches as this are apples and oranges. One is targeting a company because it is known to handle this information, the other is targeting an individual.

The difference is simply data dispersion. If a breach dump ends up on the public Internet everyone has access to that data, worst case scenario, infinitely. Individual targeting has a similar risk but the overall impact is smaller.

Not sure what your point is with the "head in the sand" comment - I happen to work for a security company in an engineering role. I'm not, in any way, defending security through obscurity or the way SSNs are used or (mis)handled. Reading through these comments it is apparent credit agencies don't even get it - and that is disturbing in itself.

But stating that you "doubt a whole lot of SSNs were gathered in this hack that weren't already effectively disseminated widely" is, in fact, a head-in-sand approach compared to doing everything you can to preserve and prevent in the mean time. I, personally, don't agree.

edit: added "compared" to second to last sentence for clarification

Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by justin66 on Thursday February 05, 2015 @01:47PM (#9005030)
> Legally you can obtain someone's SSN for very little money.

Not legally. You certainly can go onto a website and buy them, if you misrepresent your purposes, and you won't be caught... but it's still illegal.

Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by elipsey on Thursday February 05, 2015 @01:13PM (#9004796)
A company and it's customers are both victims when it gets hacked, but when it has millions of customers the external cost of poor security is so great the bad outcomes seem inevitable.

However, there would be less harm from these kinds of breaches if consumers were not obliged to prove their own innocence whenever someone loaned money in their name without rigorously verifying their identity. If someone claims to have loaned a bunch of money to me without ever interacting with me, the recovery of that foolish loan should really not be my problem. It would still be bad for an insurance company to expose private information, but there wouldn't be such a tremendous incentive to steal, agregate, and distribute this kind of data if there wasn't so much easy money in it.

Stolen credentials of the kind described in this breach are valuable largely because there is an asymmetry of effort favoring thieves: it's so much easier to borrow money in my name than it is for me prove my innocence that the process of borrowing money with other peoples' identity can be done in bulk, and to some extent automated. This situation is only sustainable because the lenders have shifted the responsibility of authentication onto their customers, retroactive to the issueance of credit. Identity verification prior to extending credit to a debtor is trivial and automated, while retroactively proving fraud has a large cost to the debtor in actual human labor.

It seems like payment systems and consumer creditors have colluded to force a Faustian bargain on us: to gain access to utilities and payment systems you have use credit, even if you don't want it. Therefore, if you want to be able to have municipal water, a place to live, or a phone, all of which are practically contingent on credit rating even if you pay with cash, you have to protect your credit rating.

It would be nice to decouple payment systems from consumer credit, but we won't. Nobody, whether they are a buissiness or the state, can afford to cross the credit card companies or the ratings agencies. They are buisiness titans with big lobbying clout. If you get taken by theives, it doesn't mattter if you're a consumer, a big corporation like Target, or a government agency like the VA, you're going under the bus because the status quo is too profitible to fix, and security is your problem. Nothing can be allowed to slow down the issuance of easy credit, or to create the slightest friction in CC transactions. Look what just happened with chip and pin? We can't even _opt into_ a pin for CC transactions because it might confuse us. While we're on the subject, go read about what happens to people who to try to build alternative payment systems that cut out MCVISA...

How many data breaches would there be if bad actors had to take the trouble to personally hassle each of the millions of people they had data on before they could take our money?

Probably some, but how much would we care who knew our SSN's or addresses if they couldn't easily be monetized?

Some, but less, I think.

Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by exelius on Thursday February 05, 2015 @03:48PM (#9005963)
I agree completely with this.

SSN should not be worth anything because it's really not different from a name. Instead of saying "hi my name is exelius", you're saying "hi my name is 302-45-9522". You wouldn't trust me if I said the former, so why the latter?

I don't know any solution to this problem that would realistically be any better. Crypto isn't a good long-term solution -- any crypto we use today will be trivially cracked by a cell phone 20 years from now. Trust mechanisms seem better, but even then they can be simulated (see: twitter bots, facebook bots, click fraud, etc.)

Identity theft is far too easy today, but even if we had an effective system that could prove identity... I'm not sure we would want that societally. It basically guarantees big brother and wraps it in the guise of security.

Tldr: this is a tricky problem where the situation caused by the solution may actually be worse than the original situation.

Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by spellboots on Thursday February 05, 2015 @04:29PM (#9006251)
> any crypto we use today will be trivially cracked by a cell phone 20 years from now.

This is completely false for correctly implemented crypto unless mobile phones of the future are made of something other than matter and occupy something other than space. It could also be that fundamental understandings of math and physics are incorrect. But the idea that just because of improved technology we'll be able to crack today's crypto is ludicrous

http://i.imgur.com/CzyO1yv.jpg

Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by k2enemy on Thursday February 05, 2015 @11:03AM (#9003893)
We really do need to find a better way of authenticating and identifying people. SSNs were never meant for this and they clearly don't fill the role successfully.

I've long been a proponent of the government announcing that they will publish everyone's SSN 2 years from now. Banks, insurance companies, the govt, etc have until then to figure better methods.

Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by Torgo on Thursday February 05, 2015 @01:11PM (#9004778)
Already in the works: National Strategy for Trusted Identities in Cyberspace (NSTIC)

http://www.nist.gov/nstic/

Combine this with a smartcard. I guess a lot of European countries already do something like this?

Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by eli on Thursday February 05, 2015 @04:13PM (#9006146)
Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by john_b on Thursday February 05, 2015 @11:30AM (#9004073)
There are plenty of better ways already. A simple public/private keypair would go a long way towards this goal.

The problem is that everyone working on crypto products focuses on just developing technology, often attempting to make existing crypto systems easier to use for ordinary people. This is fine, but it's only a partial solution. We need to educate people who don't know and don't care about proper security. Nobody is going to use the most secure and easy to use crypto system if they don't see the benefit and think that a SSN or a driver's license is a good way to show their identity.

There is a lot of hand wringing about how hard it is to get ordinary people to take security seriously, but honestly this is a problem that will solve itself given enough time and enough breaches such as this. Until people understand that only secret information--which they and only they know--can be used to authenticate them and protect their information, this will just keep happening.

Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by exelius on Thursday February 05, 2015 @11:51AM (#9004230)
SSNs are already public information. There are numerous legal ways online to enter a person's name and 1 or 2 past addresses and get their SSN back.

Their main purpose is to serve as a primary key - many people have the same name, but SSN is unique. It should never be used for establishing identity - it's about as effective as asking someone for their middle name.

Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by kanzure on Thursday February 05, 2015 @12:19PM (#9004446)
> We really do need to find a better way of authenticating and identifying people

What about not doing that at all? Hear me out. Not relying on "identity" would cost many orders of magnitude less. And besides, why should I care who you are-- what does your identity matter to me? And why should anyone else care?

Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by steego on Thursday February 05, 2015 @12:41PM (#9004594)
It sounds like you're putting the bait out so somebody will disagree with you and then you'll explain the alternative to using identity as a form of authorization.

Can you save us a long and stupid discussion and simply explain your plan to practically deploy a better authorization system that will cost many orders of magnitude less?

Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by ryandrake on Thursday February 05, 2015 @01:09PM (#9004764)
How in the world did society even function before we had a unique number to identify people? It must have been utter chaos! Before 1935 (when the first SSN was issued), there was no way to borrow money, go to college, buy land, open any kind of account anywhere, or do any of the things that somehow we need a unique number for today.
Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by Karunamon on Thursday February 05, 2015 @12:30PM (#9004520)
I couldn't care less, but someone who is granting you credit has a legitimate reason to know who they're giving money to and how likely you are to pay it back, and who to chase after if you fail to do so.

Let's not pretend there aren't valid reasons for identity to be established.

Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by snomad on Thursday February 05, 2015 @12:38PM (#9004574)
Identity is tantamount to verifying education. Colleges need to know who you are, and potential employers need to be able to identify that yes this John Smith is the one that graduated from Stanford w/a 3.8 GPA and a degree in computer science.
Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by nradov on Thursday February 05, 2015 @11:36AM (#9004120)
If you live in California, you have the right to put a security freeze on your child's credit file. This will prevent one of the most serious types of identity theft with a stolen SSN. Other states might have similar laws.

http://oag.ca.gov/idtheft/facts/freeze-your-credit

Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by zrail on Thursday February 05, 2015 @11:44AM (#9004173)
I'd just like to point out that you can put a freeze on your and your children's credit files in any state.

In most states it will cost in the neighborhood of $10 for each of the three bureaus, unless you're already the documented victim of identity theft (ask me how I know this).

Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by chandraonline on Thursday February 05, 2015 @02:23PM (#9005292)
It is not possible to put a freeze on a child's SSN until they have a credit file. So unless they have been a victim of an identity theft or have a credit file (because they have a credit card from their parent for eg) this won't work. The only thing to do for parents with minor children is to monitor their SSN for activity.
Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by jeletonskelly on Thursday February 05, 2015 @11:21AM (#9004008)
Maybe we should get a public/private key pair at birth instead.
Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by babyjake on Thursday February 05, 2015 @10:46AM (#9003786)
Thanks for the advice. Can you give some specific steps on how to "monitor your child's SSN for activity"? How would I go about doing this?
Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by at-fates-hands on Thursday February 05, 2015 @11:03AM (#9003888)
Start with Trans Union, they have a child specific application so you can find out if your child's SSN has been used by identity thieves: http://www.transunion.com/corporate/personal/fraudIdentityTh... If they don't have any reports, there's a good chance you're probably ok.

You can also apply to put a security freeze on your child's SSN. State by state laws and application process here: http://consumersunion.org/research/security-freeze/

And then there's the myriad of companies who can give you protection for a monthly fee:

AllClearID: https://www.allclearid.com/

LifeLock Junior: http://www.safety4yourkids.com

Also, Experian has a monitoring service as well specifically for kids: http://www.familysecure.com/

Hope this helps.

Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by BrokenEnso on Thursday February 05, 2015 @11:24AM (#9004030)
Just filled out the Trans Union site with dummy data to check, and none of the transaction is over SSL. So, to kind out if my child's identity has been stolen I have to expose them to identity theft....
Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by webXL on Thursday February 05, 2015 @11:32AM (#9004090)
That shocked me as well. Doesn't exactly give you a warm fuzzy feeling about a major credit reporting agency's security measures. Do some of these companies just view these breaches/vulnerabilities as a joke?
Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by nkozyra on Thursday February 05, 2015 @01:51PM (#9005068)
Wow. That is incredibly hilarious and sad. I passed the note on to TU.
Re:“Anthem was the target of a very sophisticated external c... by sprkyco on Thursday February 05, 2015 @10:55AM (#9003848)
Had never really thought of that angle. Being a father it does shake me up a bit more than usual as it seems my peers and I are quite used to these headlines being the norm. Imagining a future in which you have already been "doxed" prior to elementary school is a bit disturbing.