Re:Chairman Wheeler Proposes New Rules for Protecting the Op...
by wtallis on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @09:47PM
(#9001472)
I'm really looking forward to getting details on what will constitute "reasonable network management". If they're given the freedom to explicitly prioritize VoIP then they get to pick winners and losers when they choose how to identify and classify flows as being VoIP. Stupid or subjective QoS shouldn't be included under the reasonable network management banner, but bad QoS is so popular that I fear the commission may not know better or may not require ISPs to know better.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Chairman Wheeler Proposes New Rules for Protecting the Op...
by furyg3 on Thursday February 05, 2015 @05:47AM
(#9002602)
I don't find QoS at odds with Net Neutrality. High Netflix usage on an ISP's network shouldn't kill voice calls or interactive applications.
Deciding what goes into the 'video' 'voice' 'p2p' QoS buckets is (and will always be) fuzzy... The litmus test is 1) is payment involved? and 2) what are the offerings of the company who owns the pipes?
You don't get to charge YouTube for higher QoS over Netflix, nor can 'TimeWarner Telepresence' work fine during peak periods but FaceTime and Skype do not.
Re:Chairman Wheeler Proposes New Rules for Protecting the Op...
by wtallis on Thursday February 05, 2015 @10:38AM
(#9003732)
> High Netflix usage on an ISP's network shouldn't kill voice calls or interactive applications.
Net neutrality violations are not necessary to ensure this. On a network that does fair queuing/flow queuing, the first application to suffer from congestion will naturally be the one using the most bandwidth: Netflix, not VoIP. No explicit and subjective buckets or classification needed.