Re:Show HN: Create a perfect meal with linear programminga
by jwally on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @08:45PM
(#9001286)
Would love some feed back on my first web-app. Thanks!
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Show HN: Create a perfect meal with linear programminga
by slykat on Thursday February 05, 2015 @03:39AM
(#9002274)
Technically, I should be really interested in this app as I've been spending the last few months trying to hack my diet. However, I tuned out after a few minutes. Specifically:
* There is a huge wall of text. Most users (or at least me) want to learn what the product is by playing with it, not by reading.
* Lots of form fields before you get value. I looked at the start point and immediately walked away. A large form scares away users.
* It's weird that your height input only takes total inches instead of the normal feet + inches (users don't want to do math)
* Not sure what the value is here - if I'm a consumer and I actually know the % calories across carbs, protein, and fat then why would I need this app? people who have a metric for that (like I do) probably fall into a really small niche of health obsessed people who already know how to make their diet hit their targets. I use myFitnesspal and I know exactly how to hit my targets.
Basically my summarized feedback is focus on the UX and a broader demographic. This is an awesome problem to tackle and I like your approach but I don't think many people could benefit with it the way its currently setup.
FYI this is awesome first web app - the amount of functionality you've provided is awesome.
Re:Show HN: Create a perfect meal with linear programminga
by jwally on Thursday February 05, 2015 @07:57AM
(#9002950)
Awesome points. Thanks for the feedback. You're right, target audience is pretty niche. Bodybuilders, figure athletes, gym rats, etc.
I probably didn't communicate it well but the value of the tool is this: How do you build a meal that meets your diet goals (fat, protein, carbs) given that foods have a mix of each type.
Re:Show HN: Create a perfect meal with linear programminga
by unwind on Thursday February 05, 2015 @06:13AM
(#9002672)
Interesting way to go from problem to solution ... not sure if I can apply it (I don't think of my diet in terms of "I need x grams of protein today") but I bet there are people who do.
I think it would communicate better if it explained why "linear programming" is interesting here, and briefly what it is, rather than just linking to Wikipedia. Also, there are a lot of basic typos, you should run a spell-checker or something.
Re:Show HN: Create a perfect meal with linear programminga
by vander_elst on Thursday February 05, 2015 @07:27AM
(#9002845)
Awesome idea, it would be nice if the application proposes some meals that are a good match for the daily needs. It should be possible since you have already a big database of foods.