News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why, pray tell, is a Pre-Calculus book $235? by Someone1234 on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @02:20PM (#8998997)
Because people keep misplacing blame and as a direct result nothing ever changes.

All I keep reading is Americans blaming the evil publishers for their greed and profiteering. However that is a publisher's job. It is in their DNA, they're a profit making business, they aren't meant to do the right thing.

Instead the people who should be "blamed" are the schools/departments/academics. These are the people who assign a $235 book, these are the people who's job it is to spread knowledge and educate people. They're the "gatekeepers" and they're asleep on the job, or worse in cahoots with the publishers (because publishers give them a way to keep tuition lower, by doing the grading on your teacher's behalf via one-time-use codes, instead of the school/department needing to hire more graders or develop systems).

A lot of schools/departments/academics have solved this issue, they're developed free or "open source" books and other material. But many either don't care or are benefiting from the relationship with the publishers.

If you wish the situation to change then complain in the right direction: To the educators, school, department, or similar. Publishers are just going to laugh at your complaining with good reason.

PS - In many other countries this issue doesn't exist, not because $200+ books don't exist (they do), but because educators haven't lost sight of their role as gatekeepers to knowledge and education. Many of my own teachers wrote all of the course's material in-house and then made it available for free, they re-used the same material every year for the same course. It was like $5 to print it all out (just in photocopier/binding costs), but digital so just bring an iPad if you wish...

Re:Why, pray tell, is a Pre-Calculus book $235? by impendia on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @03:58PM (#8999721)
> Instead the people who should be "blamed" are the schools/departments/academics.

I am an academic. Unfortunately this answer is correct.

Still more unfortunately, one reason that this persists is that it's in no one's self interest to create an alternative. What I'd really like to see is momentum build for high-quality, wiki-style textbooks where lots of teachers from lots of different institutions collaborate. Unfortunately, this isn't happening much.

Re:Why, pray tell, is a Pre-Calculus book $235? by michaelbuddy on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @04:16PM (#8999871)
there are a lot of these in existence. Not a specific model to get the books into the right hands though. For example, the wikibooks if you look them up would fit the bill. And there's a model using version control like GIT to enable people to fork their own versions of the book into branches. BUT what's the divide? You have to get the book in front of the educators, and you have to make it as easy to acquire the printed item. The reason why coke and pepsi and frito lay are in every store and dominate? They keep showing up and restocking. Their product is the most available and they keep doing it. So make the book printable, easy to acquire and just as easy for the professors to say yes as it is for them to just sign a paper when the publisher's sales guy shows up with an expensive book and a small token bribe to encourage them.
Re:Why, pray tell, is a Pre-Calculus book $235? by impendia on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @04:21PM (#8999910)
There is this, for example:

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/a3/Calculus....

Not terrible, but not as good as commercial textbooks. (Please let me know if you are aware of anything better.)

Re:Why, pray tell, is a Pre-Calculus book $235? by michaelbuddy on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @05:39PM (#9000506)
I've never really browsed the mathematics area of these types of books. I do recall a story of high school teachers developing their own text making news in the past 5-7 years or so. While I don't really have time to at the moment, you'll find the best wikibooks / gitbooks.io are probably on programming. Or topics where less diagram content is involved or required. Also when it's an open source book anybody can extrapolate the content and reformat it in design software suc as indesign, scribus or whatever. The framework and methods exist, but there are gaps in the process that have made it so a professor is gonna make their own book and bind it through the campus copy shop. But we know the divide, we know a way to make it work, just need people to jump in I guess and have a reason to do it well for less cost. It will take a couple entrepreneurial people, but it would make for an attention-getting enterprise. hacker news might breed the right kind of people for this.