News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:F.C.C. Is Expected to Propose Regulating the Internet as ... by shmerl on Monday February 02, 2015 @07:15PM (#8988061)
Who would want to be negative about it except monopolists' shills who are paid to do it?
Re:F.C.C. Is Expected to Propose Regulating the Internet as ... by pekk on Tuesday February 03, 2015 @05:10AM (#8989592)
One of the two major political parties has a stronger interest in reducing government regulation across the board to give corporations greater scope, even if that means stronger monopolies. You don't have to assume paid shills to get this outcome.
Re:F.C.C. Is Expected to Propose Regulating the Internet as ... by shmerl on Tuesday February 03, 2015 @12:09PM (#8991541)
I don't get it. Why would any party prefer monopoly to free market? Formally neither Republicans nor Democrats are against free market (and preferring monopoly is being against free market). Unless of course it's all about corruption and bribery. I.e. monopolists paying those parties to do their bidding which is a common problem these days. But that again brings us back to paid shills or bought bureaucrats in this case.
Re:F.C.C. Is Expected to Propose Regulating the Internet as ... by pekk on Tuesday February 03, 2015 @12:39PM (#8991784)
OK. I'm being downvoted presumably because I sound partisan or something, butyou don't have to assume that the people posting here are paid shills because their view is politically mainstream, lots of normal people have these views without being paid. That's all I'm saying. You don't have to assume that one view is astroturfed when there are plenty of people who will line up to defend it for free.
Re:F.C.C. Is Expected to Propose Regulating the Internet as ... by shmerl on Tuesday February 03, 2015 @01:20PM (#8992070)
> you don't have to assume that the people posting here are paid shills because their view is politically mainstream

That's exactly my point. No mainstream (even partisan) view is supporting monopoly. Such views are normally expressed by corrupted politicians and paid shills. Or you are suggesting that supporting corruption is now mainstream or that some party now is officially against free market even without being corrupted?

Re:F.C.C. Is Expected to Propose Regulating the Internet as ... by pekk on Tuesday February 03, 2015 @04:17PM (#8993434)
There is definitely a mainstream view supporting the media companies, and consistently angry about all regulation. This isn't even disputable.
Re:F.C.C. Is Expected to Propose Regulating the Internet as ... by shmerl on Tuesday February 03, 2015 @05:40PM (#8994012)
> There is definitely a mainstream view supporting the media companies

Supporting companies against excessive regulations in general and supporting monopolies (i.e. preventing antitrust restrictions and supporting aticompetitive market capture) is not the same thing. The first should serve freeing the market. The second serves only reducing its freedom, nothing else.

Also, consider that exactly the same companies who are against enforcing Net neutrality are perfectly fine with the politicians which write for them state laws which ban competition. I.e. blatant excessive regulation, and very unhealthy one with that. Those are the same companies and politicians which at the same time scream about how bad regulation will be if Net neutrality will be enforced. Hypocrisy much? Or may be they simply are against regulation which weakens their monopoly and pro regulation which strengthens it?

As you can see it has nothing to do with partisan or "mainstream" views on regulation in general. It's about greedy monopolists and their bought corrupted bureaucrats. Who in their normal mind would voluntarily support such a thing?

Re:F.C.C. Is Expected to Propose Regulating the Internet as ... by fubarred on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @05:03AM (#8996067)
It might be tinfoil, but it makes one wonder why a significant net neutrality opponent (Verizon) is considering purchasing the largest (monetary) proponent (AOL). Granted VZN and AOL had joint ventures previously, but sealing such a deal would have a chilling effect.
Re:F.C.C. Is Expected to Propose Regulating the Internet as ... by MCRed on Monday February 02, 2015 @10:18PM (#8988678)
People who recognize that the internet has been a free market for most of its existence, and has consequently resulted in a massive economic boom.

Without which, by the way, there would not be the startup culture we have now. (prior to the internet it was all semiconductors.)

YC people here are advocating literally killing the goose that laid the golden egg.

Do I sound like a shill for comcast? If so, you're not really listening.

Re:F.C.C. Is Expected to Propose Regulating the Internet as ... by shmerl on Monday February 02, 2015 @10:37PM (#8988725)
> People who recognize that the internet has been a free market for most of its existence?

Really? I didn't notice any freedom in places where the only choice are some colluded monopolistic ISPs which in addition write state laws which ban competition. It's not called a free market. It's the opposite of it. All that talk about the magic "invisible hand of the market" is a pile of trash when monopoly is in place and turns that hand into a suffocating iron grip.

Re:F.C.C. Is Expected to Propose Regulating the Internet as ... by fpgeek on Tuesday February 03, 2015 @03:32AM (#8989397)
> People who recognize that the internet has been a free market for most of its existence

Really? ARPANET and NSFNET were big free market bastions, were they?

Re:F.C.C. Is Expected to Propose Regulating the Internet as ... by thoughtpolice on Tuesday February 03, 2015 @10:02AM (#8990642)
LOL, it's even better than that, AFAIK. ARPANET was a (D)ARPA project that to my knowledge was started to have computers start interoperating with each other so researchers at universities could easily and generally transfer data and information with each other, e.g. research papers.

You may have noticed the 'start' bit. The reason it was 'starting' is because prior to that, corporations did NOT want you to have computers that could talk to each other. That would weaken their grip on the market and ability to lock you in; when no computers can talk to each other, and your business depends on computers from Corp X, this is good for them: you can't go to anyone else. Printers, sockets, none of these are interoperable - you rely on them for everything.

As far as I understand, this is exactly what companies like GE did in those days. ARPANET was completely against everything they wanted, because it meant consumers were freed from their lock in. You could mix and match computers (perhaps cheaper, not-GE ones) with your GE machines, and you weren't beholden to their whims (oh, you need a better mainframe? Gotta upgrade all your machines so they can talk to each other!) And it's unlikely the 'free market' would have ever bore out the same result, and if it did, it probably would have only happened decades later.

Of course, good luck explaining this shit to a libertarian-infested hellhole like HN: they all believe they're on the cusp of Gettin' Big Bucks, so they don't want a market that allows competition, or a government that regulates anything they do. They want one that allows them to strangle competition with no repercussions or limits - they're just about to make it big after all as Uber Millionaires, and why do you want to steal their money!???!!

Like said elsewhere, Americans believe themselves to be impovershed millionaires, so they don't want to limit their future greatness. And of course, to build on what Carlin said: this is a part of the 'American Dream' because you have to be asleep (or braindead) to believe in it.

Re:F.C.C. Is Expected to Propose Regulating the Internet as ... by shmerl on Tuesday February 03, 2015 @12:17PM (#8991620)
> Of course, good luck explaining this shit to a libertarian-infested hellhole like HN: they all believe they're on the cusp of Gettin' Big Bucks, so they don't want a market that allows competition,

I'm not sure where you get this idea. Libertarians are pro competition, not anti. So they are actually quite negative towards monopolies and support their prevention.

Re:F.C.C. Is Expected to Propose Regulating the Internet as ... by thoughtpolice on Tuesday February 03, 2015 @03:13PM (#8992996)
You say this, but most Libertarians do not really give a fuck about competition, only that the government does not interfere with corporations in any way, and they get theirs (no matter the cost to anyone else). Despite the fact there is boundless amounts of evidence of companies using their influence to force monopolies or crush competition.

Oh, but Libertarians don't like that (allegedly). Well then, their answer is simple: But if you don't like that, just move! Don't support that company! Bootstrap harder! Externalities don't real! That'll show those big mean old companies (nevermind the fact you don't have the money or ability to move or go without services like the internet, making the point moot).

At the end of the day, having dealt with many of them here in Texas, most libertarians are just dumbass 20 something white male Republicans who want to smoke weed and end the Fed. They're a joke, but they're a joke that exist on this site in quite a plentiful manner, as you can see. They don't care about the monopolistic control most ISPs have over their customers in plenty of places in the US. They only care that Obama doesn't get all up in their internet; everything else be damned.

Re:F.C.C. Is Expected to Propose Regulating the Internet as ... by shmerl on Tuesday February 03, 2015 @03:42PM (#8993208)
> but most Libertarians do not really give a fuck about competition, only that the government does not interfere with corporations in any way

No, libertarians are against excessive control over society, not necessarily corporations. I.e. if corporation is a monopoly, it itself gets excessive control over society, so as such libertarians support preventing monopolies. That's the logic behind it. I've never seen a libertarian who is supporting monopoly. It simply sounds like an oxymoron to me.

Re:F.C.C. Is Expected to Propose Regulating the Internet as ... by imjustsaying on Tuesday February 03, 2015 @10:20AM (#8990792)
The government is a player in the free market.
Re:F.C.C. Is Expected to Propose Regulating the Internet as ... by billiam on Tuesday February 03, 2015 @11:25AM (#8991228)
Former network engineer here who built these big networks in the 1990s. At MCI and UUNET we used to talk about all the services we would build to compete with GeoCities and AOL. If only we didn't have to face our peers every Wednesday at informal meetings in the DC area and tell them that we would favor our own traffic over theirs at our interconnects. The traffic and interconnects were growing so fast we couldn't stop open peering and risk "killing the goose that laid the golden egg."

Now things are different. Comcast is a content company propped up by a cable monopoly. Title II? Hell yeah. But no price controls. Whatever it takes to get us to have the residential bandwidth of, say, Estonia.

Re:F.C.C. Is Expected to Propose Regulating the Internet as ... by dd36 on Tuesday February 03, 2015 @09:36AM (#8990473)
We had de facto net neutrality until Verizon successfully gutted it a year ago. The FCC is trying to maintain the free market that has existed. Verizon is trying to turn the internet into cable TV.