Re:Syntax across languages
by michaelcampbell on Monday February 02, 2015 @07:36AM
(#8983857)
> No, you're wrong.
And you and he both gave evidence to the initial assertion that "it's confusing".
Re:Syntax across languages
by gamegoblin on Monday February 02, 2015 @01:39PM
(#8985852)
I'm not sure if "confusing" is fair -- just different than C-family languages.
The rule is simply "The first expression is a function, all following expressions are arguments to that function"
It's no different than "The first symbol is a function, all comma-separated, parentheses-bound expressions are arguments to that function"
Both are pretty easy syntactic rules, I think.
Re:Syntax across languages
by JoeAltmaier on Monday February 02, 2015 @01:41PM
(#8985865)
Its arguably confusing, due to the lack of parentheses factoring a list of functions into one or more invocations. How is the nesting done here? Something more subtle. A lifetime of reading parenthesized functions is going to be confounded by changing the convention - which equals 'confusing'
Re:Syntax across languages
by gamegoblin on Monday February 02, 2015 @01:52PM
(#8985949)
I think you're probably overestimating the difference. Here is an algorithm for mechanically transforming a C function call to a Haskell function call:
for all arguments in the function
if the argument is not a symbol surround it with parentheses
delete all commas
delete the two initial parentheses
And an algorithm for converting Haskell calls to C calls: put an open parenthesis between the first expression and second expression
put a close parenthesis at the end of the expression
put commas between all expressions between these two parentheses
The fact that it's so easy to convert between them highlights to me that they are both pretty easy.I understand currying and partial function application. That's not the problem. The problem is that function application whitespace demands an arbitrary application precedence and obscures function signature to the reader.
Currying allows simple partial application; if A is a function that "takes 3 arguments" (i.e. it has type `w -> x -> y -> z`, which means that it takes an argument of type `w` and returns a function with type `x -> y -> z`, which takes an argument ...), you can say e.g.
where `A_` is the partially applied function `A`.