Singapore (14% of GDP) and Hong Kong (13% of GDP) are low tax economies.
Japan and Australia are similar to the US, and are not considered low tax countries. The US and Japan also share the distinction of having among the highest corporate tax rates on earth.
E.g. in Scandinavia, the horrors of U.S. are attributed to its "extremy low" tax status. Horrors like that rich people only live in compounds surrounded by walls and armed guards, and the poor are dying because of no health care and no food, and the middle class does not exist. Yes, I know it sounds rather extreme but this is common rhetoric in countries where the tax rates are >40%.
Election time is never far away.
"Horrors like that rich people only live in compounds surrounded by walls and armed guards, and the poor are dying because of no health care and no food, and the middle class does not exist."
The poor have essentially universal free healthcare in the US and have for a long time. I should know, I've used it before, and it's very easy to use. The poor also have the benefit of the one of the largest welfare states on earth, including the largest food and subsidized housing programs.
The US has the world's largest true middle class, with a median income among the highest of any country. A mere 1% of US labor earns the minimum wage, and the majority of those people are below the age of 25. The US also has a higher labor force participation rate than nearly all of Europe - while simultaneously having a high median income.
The US has a lower unemployment rate than: Sweden, Finland, Denmark, the Netherlands, Belgium, France, United Kingdom, Spain, Portugal, Greece.
And while Europe rolls around in a near depression, with Europe's GDP still at 2007 levels (since 2007 the US has added $3.5 trillion to its GDP) and high unemployment, US wages are expanding at the fastest pace in a decade, while unemployment keeps falling, which will drive even faster wage growth in the next few years.
What? That's patently false. Medicaid provides access to a wide range of providers and requires almost no financial contribution (you get a prescription filled and it's $3-5; if you can't pay it's free).
As for preventative care, it's actually a focus of Medicaid! There are numerous programs offered that provide preventative care for pregnant women and children. [1]
[1]http://www.medicaid.gov/medicaid-chip-program-information/by...
Qualifying for Medicaid is onerous and most are "not poor enough".
Thanks for the almost completely irrelevant link though, really managed to waste a lot of my time.
The ACA just increased Medicaid eligibility to 133% of the Federal Poverty Level (~$40K for a family of 4). I would argue that's a pretty reasonable cutoff for those in need.
This is an often-repeated myth that doesn't hold up when you consider the tax breaks afforded to corporations in the U.S.
The corporate tax rate is high in number, but when you factor in exemptions, the U.S. is quite competitive in this regard. Reuters reported in 2013 that corporations utilized $180B in tax breaks. [0]
[0] http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/04/15/us-usa-tax-corpora...
And yes, the Baltics do have a bad ratio of taxes collected, versus value received.
However, I'd claim taxes in proportion to GDP are a fairly good indicator of taxes in proportion to income, because income and GDP are strongly related. In fact, one way to define GDP is "the sum of primary incomes distributed by resident producer units" and the same number may be called GDI, "gross domestic income".
Nominally, yes, but the effective corporate tax rate is much lower [1]. US income tax is at the low end for the developed world, too (both nominal and effective).
[1] http://money.cnn.com/2013/07/01/news/economy/corporate-tax-r...
The US doesn't have a VAT, but it does have a sales tax, which is pretty low compared to VAT in most European countries[2]
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value-added_tax#EU_countries
[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sales_taxes_in_the_United_State...
Land value tax would be even better, because the land does not run away or stop working. How's that in Greece?
Land Value tax makes the rich pay a lot but hits the poorest really hard since the threshold to owning land (and creating wealth) is substantially raised.
That seems a bizarre statement. Firstly I don't see any connection between owning land and creating wealth. Secondly taxing land value is a deterrent to land ownership and should reduce the desirability of owning land and reduce the price of land. This will make it more cheaply available to productive use and reduce the incentive to hoard land unproductively. Finally the poorest cannot afford to own land anyway so are not affected by the land taxes.
Have I missed something?
BTW I largely agree about cheating VAT especially in a small country with neighbouring countries that can be cheaply visited.
We can agree that the reason for owning land is to make money, yes? Planting crops would take a couple of months to return the initial investment. If I planted a forest it could take years.
If this investment possibility is removed from everyone without (massive amounts of, if the tax is high enough) capital it's going to create a further wealth gap for no apparent reason.
> Finally the poorest cannot afford to own land anyway so are not affected by the land taxes.
Yes, this is true for the poorest, bad phrasing on my part, but it is going to make the barrier of entry higher.
Also: land produces goods that everyone need the same amount of (food, wood, wool), this would increase prices in a way that wouldn't really bother the capital heavy but would seriously hurt the already poor.
The ROI on a forest takes years whether or not the land value is taxed. You also said earlier that it was a tax on land value so presumably much lower for forestry land than urban land.
The primary impact of a land value tax is likely to be on the price of land itself because land will be less profitable. Introduction or increase will hurt those who own land (and its abolition would benefit land owners).
If we assume that the cost of access to land (rent) is set by the free market then we can assume that demand is essentially unchanged and the supply of land would if anything be increased (if some speculators sell or start to rent out their land) so access to land for the less wealthy should be cheaper.
I think your assumption that ownership is the way that less wealthy access land is fundamentally wrong. I think that this will also apply to the effect on prices of things made on the land on which I expect little impact (although there may be side effects on the rental market that make this more complicated).
As someone from Oregon... that definitely varies by jurisdiction, as your link shows :-)
A lot of the people frequenting HN are (usually) well off IT workers - so I find the following list quite telling - it shows an effective income tax and social security rates on USD $100,000 of gross income (based on KPMG 2012 global tax rate survey): http://imgur.com/MUZlz
Usually different comparisons concentrate on "average" workers, i.e. lower income.
> taxes are very high
Doesn't seem so: Croatia's tax to GDP ratio is 26.6 %. Compare that to 46.8 % in Belgium, 43.4 % in Austria, 40.6 % in Germany, 45.8 % in Sweden. 26.9 % in U.S. which is internationally known as a low-tax regime.
Surely some taxes are high, and taxation is not necessarily fair, but I'd say that Croatia's taxes overall are not high. I would also expect that the "black market" GDP is higher there than in "old" EU countries, say Germany or even France, or the U.S. Though I admit this is mostly based on just prejudice.
(Using Heritage Foundation figures in http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_tax_revenu... - OECD numbers are slightly different but not that much)