News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chemists Confirm the Existence of New Type of Bond by oasisbob on Friday January 30, 2015 @11:02AM (#8972622)
Sounds like more of a pseudo-isotope?

I thought proton equivalency was the fundamental definition of an isotope, though perhaps that's just a lie you feed chemistry undergrads.

Re:Chemists Confirm the Existence of New Type of Bond by saalweachter on Friday January 30, 2015 @11:50AM (#8972855)
The antimuon is "proton-like" for a lot of purposes: it has a +1 charge and it's much heavier than an electron. So you've got a heavy bit with +1 charge and an electron orbiting it, you call it hydrogen.
Re:Chemists Confirm the Existence of New Type of Bond by tjradcliffe on Friday January 30, 2015 @12:09PM (#8972963)
It would have been very nice had the article said that, and described what "muonium" is. I took it to be a proton plus a muon, not an anti-muon plus an electron.

To describe it as "a hydrogen isotope" is just about the optimal mix of uninformative and misleading!

Re:Chemists Confirm the Existence of New Type of Bond by logfromblammo on Friday January 30, 2015 @12:44PM (#8973186)
It's probably as close as you can get to accuracy while still keeping those who passed their high school chemistry classes in your audience.

For the purposes of explanation, the antimuon-electron pair is chemically similar enough to a proton-electron pair to call it an isotope. It has a +1 massive center, with a probability distribution for a less-massive -1 charge cloud.

Deuterium and tritium, two true isotopes of hydrogen, increase the mass of the center by adding neutrons. An antimuon is, I think, about 10% the mass of a proton. So muonium would act a lot like extra-light hydrogen for the instant before it decays.

It would have been clearer to call it an "exotic atom, chemically similar to hydrogen", though. That wouldn't conflict with the common definition of isotope as an atom with the same number of protons as the reference atom, but with a different number of neutrons.

I'm actually not aware of any exotic atoms that are not chemically similar to hydrogen or antihydrogen, as getting an exotic helium-like atom would require forming a +2 exotic center and making two -1 charges interact with it before it decays. That is likely beyond our current capabilities.

Re:Chemists Confirm the Existence of New Type of Bond by Coincoin on Friday January 30, 2015 @03:42PM (#8974364)
That's funny, because despite having no clue what muonium is, I instantly knew that line was typical science journalism bullshit. Am I too cynical or does dumbing down something to the point it makes no sense have actual value for some people?