the most common feedback was "I've always been looking for a group where I could have meaningful conversations about 'bigger' things in life, or more personal things.", and people would often keep returning.
I'm probably going to start something similar in Berlin in a month or so. It's really fun, and a great way to make friends.
> ...keep the discussion from being overtly religious (while respecting those who were religious).
I generally don't feel respected when people ask me to leave part of my identity and lifestyle at the door. I understand the aversion to fiery sermons (I'm not a huge fan either), but asking people to not be overtly themselves can be very exclusionary, especially if you are shooting for inclusiveness and authenticity.
But trying to have meaningful relationships is a great thing. It's certainly harder than it looks. Good luck!