Re:'YOUTUBE is EVIL': Somebody had a tape running, Google
by ta_544264 on Thursday January 29, 2015 @10:50AM
(#8966775)
To play devil's advocate, though, why should Google provide access to the network they have and the value it provides, while making it easy to dilute the value content creators provide?
In other words, from Google's point of view, Zoe Keating provides content for Google, for Google's benefit, not her benefit, or the benefit of her fans. In exchange, she doesn't have to run her own multimillion dollar content server. Recognizing the business they're in (advertising driven by user-provided content) doesn't seem 'draconian,' and there are other options available. If she can't accept alternatives then perhaps it proves that she needs Google a lot more than they need her.
Re:'YOUTUBE is EVIL': Somebody had a tape running, Google
by kemiller on Thursday January 29, 2015 @11:06AM
(#8966884)
Well, they do have that right, but Zoe also has the right to expose those terms to public scrutiny. Google and other monetization networks tend to promote the fact that buy paying them you're also supporting the artists, and if that's a lie, end users are rightly going to be pissed.
you can't release any music without also putting it on YouTube at the same time
Which is a pretty draconian clause.