News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Guido's Proposal: Moratorium on Python language changes by jnoller on Wednesday October 21, 2009 @05:11PM (#895623)
The GIL is an implementation detail; not a bug.
Re:Guido's Proposal: Moratorium on Python language changes by amalcon on Wednesday October 21, 2009 @05:49PM (#895708)
Calling the GIL an implementation detail is like calling tail call elimination an implementation detail: for most software, it may be so, but there are idioms one may or may not be able to use depending on that detail. It's a visible implementation detail.
Re:Guido's Proposal: Moratorium on Python language changes by jnoller on Wednesday October 21, 2009 @07:49PM (#895901)
tail call elimination is a language feature. The GIL is an implementation detail of the Cpython interpreter. Jython, IronPython, and one day PyPy and Unladen-Swallow will not have a GIL.

Ergo, it is an implementation detail.

Re:Guido's Proposal: Moratorium on Python language changes by aceofspades19 on Wednesday October 21, 2009 @06:41PM (#895801)
Well, in other implementations like jython and iron python, the GIL doesn't exist, so I think most people would consider it just an implementation detail
Re:Guido's Proposal: Moratorium on Python language changes by ubernostrum on Wednesday October 21, 2009 @07:09PM (#895848)
Tail-call is an implementation detail. The fact that some people think it's as fundamental to programming as the Ten Commandments is to the Judeo-Christian tradition is... well, perhaps more a problem with programmers than with language implementations.

(and yes, it's visible, and that's one reason why I have issues with it -- it's a classic leaky abstraction, except in this case the "leak" is more like a torrential flood)

Re:Guido's Proposal: Moratorium on Python language changes by eru on Thursday October 22, 2009 @06:10AM (#896457)
If your `while'-loops would crash after a certain number of iterations (and use linear memory before that), would you call that an implementation detail or a leaky abstraction? I'd call it a bug.

And special case constructs for linear recursion like `for' and `while' are only a necessary band-aid in languages that do not treat functions properly.

Re:Guido's Proposal: Moratorium on Python language changes by ubernostrum on Thursday October 22, 2009 @04:57PM (#897642)
Thank you for making my point eloquently.

The assumption that the way you prefer to write code should be the only way to write code is, well, exactly what I was talking about.