Re:Encrypting Your Dropbox Seamlessly and Automatically
by cperciva on Wednesday October 21, 2009 @03:07PM
(#895411)
The key to dropbox's awesomeness is delta compression, which this is totally going to destroy
Not necessarily. It looks like encfs is vulnerable to a cleaning lady attack, in which case dropbox (acting as cleaning lady) will be able to recognize and take advantage of unmodified blocks.
That said, this approach won't be able to recognize blocks which are duplicated (rather than merely unmodified) either within a file or between two different files (actually, I'm not sure if dropbox can recognize data duplicated between different files, even without encryption; but tarsnap can), and sensible generally want their encrypted filesystems to be secure -- so this really isn't a very good solution.
Not necessarily. It looks like encfs is vulnerable to a cleaning lady attack, in which case dropbox (acting as cleaning lady) will be able to recognize and take advantage of unmodified blocks.
That said, this approach won't be able to recognize blocks which are duplicated (rather than merely unmodified) either within a file or between two different files (actually, I'm not sure if dropbox can recognize data duplicated between different files, even without encryption; but tarsnap can), and sensible generally want their encrypted filesystems to be secure -- so this really isn't a very good solution.