Re:Facebook Said to Block Pages Critical of Muhammad to Avoi...
by capkutay on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @01:06AM
(#8951482)
West-Aligned Turks are engaged in an active debate and protests [0]. But like you said, they're a minority (a large minority) so they cannot succeed in electing a political party that can restore their Western, Secular values
0: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2013%E2%80%9314_protests_in_Tur...
Re:Facebook Said to Block Pages Critical of Muhammad to Avoi...
by stickfigure on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @03:34AM
(#8952032)
It is still an open question as to whether progressive interests would be better served by having Facebook blocked. Certainly some percentage of conservative Turks use Facebook; blocking Facebook is a decision to forego something they may value. Right now they get to have their pie and eat it too. I'm not sure that is healthy.
Re:Facebook Said to Block Pages Critical of Muhammad to Avoi...
by wavefunction on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @10:13AM
(#8953351)
What you've posted is idealist but unrealistic and poorly considered imo, especially if you have been following Turkish politics lately. facebook in the West is a lot of people posting funny cat pictures but in a place like Turkey it can be one of the few methods for the Western-leaning Turks to organize and communicate.
I would suggest you read up on the Iranian revolution against the Shah. Your suggestion is exactly what the Shah did on behest of the UK and USA: he came down real hard on the pro-democracy cosmopolitan youth breaking up their meetings and demonstrations. Meanwhile the hardline religious zealots could still go to mosque and organize themselves there. End result: the sort of people we might like to support in Iran were marginalized and the Ayatollah seized power. You're suggesting a similar course of action and I would predict a similar outcome.
Perhaps the 20 million Turks who are more sympathetic to Western values should be engaged in active debate with the 54 million who apparently aren't.