News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Coding is not the new literacy by mncolinlee on Monday January 26, 2015 @03:50PM (#8949487)
In a technical sense, you're 100% correct. If there's a better way to teach the same concepts without actually programming, that would be really useful. In a pragmatic sense, it's not helpful to the cause.

For engineers, it's easy to get concerned about the trees and miss the forest. If a time-strapped journalist comes across a highly-upvoted blog post on a tech site, the headline won't be , "Engineer suggests strong alternatives to coding in school." It'll be closer to, "Coder suggests kids shouldn't code."

Pedantry is a luxury our profession heaps on the world, often without regard for how our subtle nuance is completely missed.

Re:Coding is not the new literacy by ibdknox on Monday January 26, 2015 @03:56PM (#8949513)
> If there's a better way to teach the same concepts without actually programming, that would be really useful. In a pragmatic sense, it's not helpful to the cause.

These seem contradictory. We can either teach a narrow swatch of people to "code" or we can search for other ways to impart the important bit: modeling. The entire argument of the essay is that we should be looking for those "really useful" ways.

> If a time-strapped journalist comes across a highly-upvoted blog post on a tech site

I'm not sure focusing on getting a message out to someone who won't read the entire post is a worthwhile pursuit.

Re:Coding is not the new literacy by mncolinlee on Monday January 26, 2015 @05:10PM (#8949915)
Maybe I'm being too wordy. It's not what you say, but the way you say it. If you're suggesting an alternative means, don't sell it upfront as "don't teach coding."