Re:The risk psychology of the anti-vaccine movement
by gcheong on Wednesday October 21, 2009 @01:17PM
(#895108)
The flu vaccine is very hit or miss as there are multiple strains each year and vaccines are only developed for the strains most likely to be the most active each year so there are many possible explanations for your case, but one thing is certain - the vaccine did not cause you to get the flu as a dead/weakened virus cannot cause the illness. Also, you may have had the flu before but not recognized it so I'm not sure you could say you've never had it before except that one time unless you've done extensive blood testing. But let's say you really never did have the flu except that one time, well, if millions of people are tossing coins you would expect that there will be cases where for some people it always comes up heads with one tail.
Re:The risk psychology of the anti-vaccine movement
by nollidge on Wednesday October 21, 2009 @01:02PM
(#895056)
Correlation is not causation. Correlation is not causation. Correlation is not causation.
Edit: "I can't explain my flu infection"
I can. You got the flu strain which wasn't covered by the shot.
Re:The risk psychology of the anti-vaccine movement
by eru on Wednesday October 21, 2009 @12:53PM
(#895034)
I tried to re-upmod your post back to 1 point.
You state an observation. And while that anecdote flys in the face of what many here (including myself) believe about vaccination, there's nothing wrong with your comment.
For what its worth, I had have lots of flus, but was never vaccinated against influenza (as far as I can remember).
Re:The risk psychology of the anti-vaccine movement
by sketerpot on Wednesday October 21, 2009 @01:45PM
(#895193)
The observation isn't inconsistent with the facts about vaccination. Flu vaccines can't protect against every strain you might encounter, and it's a simple matter of probability that there are going to be a lot of people who get vaccinated for the first time, get a flu that year, and stop getting vaccinated from then on.
This is why anecdotal evidence on this issue is worthless. Worse than worthless, actually, since it distracts from the proper statistical approach to thinking about vaccines.
Edit: Not saying I don't believe in vaccines in general. But I'm not sure I believe in the flu vaccine. I can't explain my flu infection, nor can others who experienced the same circumstance: getting the flu the only year they were vaccinated.
I have been vaccinated against other diseases since then though.